West Coast swept aside the Fitzroy Lions with an easy 66 point win at the Western Oval. Fitzroy were held to just two behinds after half-time, unable to break through the Eagles hardened defence in wet and heavy conditions.
On a cold, wintry afternoon where a crowd of just 5,334 braved the conditions, Chris Lewis provided the shine with 16 disposals and three first half goals, as well as having a hand in several others. Peter Sumich also finished with three goals as he continued to build his match fitness from consecutive hamstring injuries.
The Eagles strong performance came despite missing several key players. Brett Heady was never a chance of lining up after dislocating his shoulder the week before against Richmond, while Chris Mainwaring (hamstring) and Chris Waterman (foot) were ruled out during the week.
John Worsfold was given an extra week to recover from his groin problem, as was Tony Evans who had a back complaint. The Eagles consequently made four changes at the selection table, with Michael Brennan returning from injury, and fringe players Matt Clape, Brendan Krummel and Paul Symmons all earning call-ups.
Damien Hampson was initially dropped, alongside injured trio Heady, Mainwaring and Waterman, but earned a reprieve ahead of the opening bounce when David Hynes pulled out.
Krummel’s selection marked his first Eagles appearance in over a year, but it didn’t come without controversy. After being named in the Eagles squad on Thursday night, Krummel became the centre of an investigation over an incident from the previous weeks WAFL derby between East Fremantle and South Fremantle.
Young Bulldog Owen Woods was collected behind the play, suffering a broken jaw in several places, and South Fremantle officials pointed the finger at Krummel. The Bulldogs lodged an official complaint with the WAFL and demanded that Krummel be charged, with Woods expected to miss the remainder of the season after undergoing surgery.
However, the WAFL tribunal were unable to determine whether there would be a case to answer, leaving Krummel free to play with West Coast. Krummel, for his part, said that he knew nothing of the incident.
The Lions dropped four players in response to their narrow loss to Brisbane the week before, with Tom Kavanagh, Danny Morton, James Manson and Nick Mitchell all losing their place. Rick Lyon, Brett Cook, Trent Cummings and Mark Zanotti were the four inclusions, but Zanotti and Cummings then became late withdrawals ahead of the match. Their spots were in turn taken by David Bain and Marcus Seecamp.
Despite the wet conditions, Malthouse started three talls in the Eagles forward line, as he looked to expose the depleted Fitzroy defence. Ashley McIntosh and Jason Ball took their spots across half forward, with Peter Sumich taking his regular spot in the goal square.
Fitzroy had first use of the wind, but the Eagles got first blood when Lewis soccered home from the goal square. The Lions held on for much of the quarter, but a three goal burst in time-on put West Coast out to a 17 point lead at the first change and there was never any coming back for the Lions from there.
The Eagles would extend their lead to 26 by the major break, then leading by 47 at three quarter time and finally running out 66 point winners as Fitzroy failed to register a second-half major. In fact, the Lions remained scoreless after half-time until the dying minutes of the last term when they kicked consecutive behinds.
When the game was there to be won, Lewis was a cut above most others on the field, proving a constant danger and giving Fitzroy defender Steven Stretch the run-around. Peter Matera added the flashes of brilliance, getting the better of Michael Dunstan on the wing, while down back the Eagles defence proved impenetrable.
Michael Brennan held Darren Wheildon to just one goal, while Guy McKenna, Glen Jakovich and Mitchell White all shut out their opponents in a complete display.
The win further enhanced this Eagles group with the club not always renowned for their performances in the wet. However, the win over Fitzroy was the fourth win in wet weather after victories over St Kilda, Essendon and Richmond in recent weeks, all of which were played in the rain.
The performance impressed Fitzroy coach Robert Shaw, declaring West Coast as ‘the best team I have seen in those conditions’.
Eagles coach Mick Malthouse acknowledged that the conditions suited the more developed Eagles against a young Fitzroy outfit. “Jarrod Molloy is a good marking player so the conditions didn’t suit him. Chris Johnson has great pace but is still finding his way.”
“We had a lot of experienced players in the midfield.”
Shaw though was far more circumspect over the difference between the two sides. “They played the percentages and followed the basic principles a lot better than us.”
“And they did it for longer and more often.”
While Lewis and Matera were the polish up forward and around the wings, Dean Kemp and Don Pyke provided the grunt through the midfield. Kemp finished with 28 disposals and a goal while Pyke had 30 through the centre. Ashley McIntosh had 18 disposals, four marks and booted 2.2 across half forward, while Glen Jakovich collected 20 touches across half back.
Paul Roos was clearly the best player for Fitzroy, gathering 31 disposals and booting a goal in an intriguing battle with Craig Turley through the middle. Jim Wynd also found plenty of the ball, finishing with 29 disposals and joined Roos as one of the Lions’ three goal kickers.
The win saw West Coast hold their one game advantage over the Blues, who defeated an inaccurate Hawthorn by 32 points at Princes Park. The Blues, in turn, held their position in second ahead of North Melbourne, with the Kangaroos coming from behind to defeat Footscray by 20 points in a Friday night classic.
Richmond became the benefactors of the losses suffered by the Hawks and the Bulldogs, climbing into the top four after their straight forward win over Sydney. Melbourne were the other big movers, storming into the top eight for the first time since Round 13. The Demons thumped a faltering Essendon by 77 points, lifting them from ninth to fifth on the ladder as they passed a number of clubs – including the Bombers – with a superior percentage.
Melbourne led a group of five teams who all had nine wins as the race for the bottom half of the top eight continued to tighten. The Cats rose to sixth after they thrashed Adelaide, with Hawthorn and Footscray filling out the rest of the finals positions. The Magpies slipped to ninth due to having the bye.
While West Coast were all but guaranteed finals and strengthened their position on a top two finish and two home finals, the fallout for Fitzroy was substantial.
Robert Shaw resigned as coach in the days following the Eagles defeat, although he agreed to coach out the remainder of the season as the Lions continued to be the centrepiece of merger discussions. Speculation suggested that a deal with either Brisbane or Melbourne was imminent, leading Fremantle to claim they should be given first right to Fitzroy players as part of their inaugural 1995 squad.
The comments angered president Dyson Hore-Lacy, who had already been vocal about the Dockers’ attempts to lure Paul Roos west with a ‘substantial’ offer, which included the captaincy. Hore-Lacy remained resolute about Fitzroy’s future, declaring the club wouldn’t hold back from launching legal action against any AFL club who tried to poach their players while under contract.
Hore-Lacy also scoffed at the idea the club would head interstate, saying a merger with the Bears would be ‘like taking the last chair on the Titanic.’
sportsphrase.blog 