Centremetres in it as Eagles Survive Late Docker Comeback

West Coast held on for a one point victory in one of the most gripping Western derbies seen between the Eagles and Dockers.

Fremantle goalsneak Hayden Ballantine had the chance to steal the unlikeliest of wins for the Dockers after the siren, with his long range effort from the boundary unable to clear the hoard of players positioned on the Fremantle goal line.

The result had important top eight implications for both teams, with the fine line in finish and margin keeping the Eagles in control of their top four destiny, while leaving the Dockers at the mercy of the chasing teams looking to force their way into September qualifications.

A win to Fremantle would have seen them join level with the Eagles on ten wins, but instead West Coast were able to open up a two game break on their closest rivals and keep the pressure on Carlton and Hawthorn for the double chance.

The frenzied finish belied the match and much of the build up as the two clubs remained cagey over their line ups.

Nic Naitanui and Jack Darling both failed to train during the week suggesting they could miss, while the Dockers were surprisingly touting the prospect of ruckman Aaron Sandilands returning despite a recurrence of a toe injury just three weeks earlier.

Mark Harvey then lit a fuse at the customary joint pre-match press conference between the two coaches when he declared the Dockers wouldn’t be caught out by West Coast as they had in the previous meeting earlier in the season.

Harvey suggested the Eagles had been ‘leaked intelligence’ before the match, which West Coast won by 33 points despite losing Daniel Kerr and Andrew Embley in the hour before the match. Further pressed, Harvey intimated the Eagles had gained information on personnel and planning which had aided them in claiming the win. Harvey was defiant in that the Eagles wouldn’t be able to rely on such assistance this time around.

A bemused John Worsfold added nothing to the accusations, other than to say he wasn’t aware of any leak. “I am not sure where all of that has come from.”

Much of the speculation during the week over line-ups ultimately came to nothing with both Jack Darling and Nic Naitanui picked for West Coast and Aaron Sandilands failing to come up. Daniel Kerr would miss a second straight week officially due to soreness with the Eagles taking precaution over their veteran midfielder.

Patrick McGinnity was the one change from the defeat to St Kilda the week before, replacing Koby Stevens. The Dockers made two changes, with Roger Hayden ruled out after breaking his leg against the Swans the week before, while 2008 rising star winner Rhys Palmer was dropped as doubt swirled around his future at the club.

Palmer had yet to sign a new contract with the Dockers with the expectation he would join the incumbent 18^th AFL side, Greater Western Sydney at the end of the season. Nick Suban and Ryan Crowley were the two inclusions for the Dockers.

Although West Coast started the match as strong favourites, the Dockers held sway through the first half.

The Eagles had been expected to hold a considerable advantage in the ruck with Cox and Naitanui over Jon Griffin and Zac Clarke, and while that was the case in the ruck knocks, the Dockers through Matthew Pavlich and Michael Barlow ensured they would match West Coast in the clearances.

The first half was a tight affair that provided little in the way of space or clean skills. Stephen Hill had a rare chance to run and carry when he bounced his way from half back through the middle of Subiaco Oval to kick the game’s opener.

Michael Barlow added a second for Fremantle to give them an early break, with Jack Darling adding the only other goal for the quarter following a crunching tackle by Darren Glass on the wing on Ballantine.

Two goals in four minutes early in the second quarter to Matt Priddis and Josh Kennedy put West Coast in front for the first time, but couldn’t muster much more in their forward half as Fremantle spent the quarter edging closer.

The Dockers managed one goal for the term, with Zac Clarke marched close to goal after Nic Naitanui initially infringed the ruckman in a marking contest and then failed to adequately hand the ball back in time.

The evenness in the game showed on the scoreboard with the Eagles holding a slender one point lead at the main break, but West Coast would exert their mark on the game from the third quarter. The Eagles had 10 scoring shots to just four, but inaccuracy prevented them from wrapping the game up.

West Coast booted 3.7 for the term but handed the Dockers simple goals with a turnover that ended with Adam McPhee and another 50m penalty to Zac Clarke for his second of the match. However, the Dockers were dealt a blow when Jon Griffin limped off with a knee injury, leaving Clarke to hold up the ruck against the Eagles pairing.

Dean Cox took full advantage en route to being awarded the Glendinning medal. Cox would finish with 42 hit-outs for the match, 27 of which came after half time as he fed the likes of Luke Shuey (26 disposals, eight clearances) and Matt Rosa (21 disposals, five clearances).

The Eagles worked their way to a seven point lead at the final change with late goals to Kennedy and LeCras and the game looked as good as done by midway through the final term when Kennedy added a third and Luke Shuey out-pointed Barlow in the goal square to stretch the Eagles advantage to 22 points.

Fremantle appeared out of shots through the last quarter as the Eagles controlled the forward half possession and their lead should have been far greater. Cox and Kennedy both missed sitters in front of goal, LeCras kicked into the man on the mark and Kennedy sent another chance out on the full.

A dour contest seemed set to reach its anticipated conclusion before Fremantle sparked into life in the final minutes through the efforts of second-year midfielder Nat Fyfe.

Fyfe got on the end of an Eagles turnover on the wing to carry the ball to the Dockers forward 50 before launching a shot on goal that drifted wide but landed with teammate Stephen Hill to kick his second of the match.

A minute later, with the Eagles looking to play conservatively and run down the clock, Fyfe won a contested ball to set Chris Mayne into space, with the half forward running the ball all the way to the goal line to draw the Dockers back within nine points.

Fyfe then added a third successive goal when Darren Glass gave away the Eagles’ third 50m penalty for the afternoon. Suddenly, in no time, the Dockers had closed to within a couple of points and had all of the momentum.

West Coast, seeming comfortable for much of the quarter, were now in desperation mode as Fremantle continued to press forward. Mayne was denied a pack mark that had correctly been adjudged to come off multiple hands, before Luke McPharlin was unlucky not to receive a free kick for high contact at the top of the goal square.

The ensuing scramble in the goal square ended with Priddis rushing a behind to reduce the margin to two points and give West Coast possession with a minute to play. Alex Silvagni won the ball back on the wing, but his kick to half forward missed the target, allowing Quinten Lynch to gather and kick for space onto the opposite wing.

Fremantle had one final thrust forward as the clock counted down to zero. A long kick from Tendai Mzungu was unable to be marked by Barlow and as the ball bobbled around a pack of players, Rosa sought refuge towards the boundary line.

However, the umpire called deliberate and the final play of an absorbing contest rested with Hayden Ballantine after the siren.

Taking possession at the apex of the boundary line and the 50m arc, the kick seemed beyond the small forward, but Ballantine flushed the kick as well as he possibly could have. For the mostly Fremantle crowd, and the kicker himself, the ball seemed to have enough but the ecstasy of celebration quickly dropped to agony and despair as the kick faded late to fall into the mass of players and only register a behind – leaving the Eagles one point victors.

The after-the-siren drama saw rare emotion from Worsfold, who ran onto the field after the final score was confirmed to celebrate with his players. But, while happy with the four points, the Eagles coach reflected on poor errors and discipline that could easily have given up the result.

“We got the win but it was real hard work, real hard work.”

Three of Fremantle’s nine goals came directly from 50m penalties, while Worsfold also bemoaned the ease of some of the other scores they conceded. “Heaps to learn from it and to know we have got to get a bit better again.”

Fremantle coach Mark Harvey praised the resilience of his side, for pushing towards the end, although he admitted he held little hope for Ballantine to come through with the winner from beyond 50m.

“My immediate thought was that it was going to be hard to kick a goal from that far out. I was expecting he might try a torpedo. He nearly got there anyway but it doesn’t come down to that kick. It comes down to prior events.”

Harvey admitted his side allowed the Eagles to control possession too much through the second half, with West Coast tallying 110 marks for the game. “We probably allowed them to kick the ball around too much at times, especially down back.”

“It was a credit to our blokes to come off the trip we had last week and kick the last three goals.”

“I would like to think that we never know when the end is near.”

Cox tallied 22 disposals and a number of important marks in the final term as part of his medal-winning performance, although Shuey arguably was the Eagles’ best with his showing in the midfield. With both Matt Priddis and Andrew Embley well held by Crowley and Mzungu, Shuey picked up the slack around the stoppages, along with Scott Selwood, who won his battle with Matthew Pavlich, and Matt Rosa.

Mark LeCras picked up 22 touches and booted two goals, both of which came in the third term. LeCras was largely contained by Garrick Ibbotson, but broke free in the second half with 14 disposals and a brace of majors. Beau Waters was inspirational with 23 touches and a courageous effort in the third quarter when he backpeddled into oncoming traffic to mark deep in defence as Mayne crashed into the back of him.

Josh Kennedy finished with 3.4 for the match, while in defence Darren Glass and Adam Selwood were resolute. Glass limited the impact of Chris Mayne while Selwood had the job on Ballantine. Matt de Boer was assigned the defensive forward role on half back Shannon Hurn, but Hurn was still able to collect 17 disposals and six rebound 50s as the Eagles defensive group held firm throughout the day.

Michael Barlow and Greg Broughton were the leading ball winners for Fremantle with 26 each with Barlow the Docker’s most consistent performer on the day, just three weeks after returning from a horror broken leg. Luke McPharlin won his duel with Jack Darling to have 20 disposals and seven marks and Fyfe lifted in the final term with eight disposals to finish with 19 touches and five inside-50s.

Importantly for West Coast, their pursuit of the top four remained on track, despite the strong wins of Carlton and Hawthorn over the weekend. The Blues smashed Essendon by 74 points with Eddie Betts booting eight goals and the Hawks had the better of Melbourne to the tune of nine goals.

As good as those wins for Carlton and Hawthorn were, the defeats for Essendon and Melbourne could not have been more demoralising. The Bombers tumbled out of the eight as a result with St Kilda taking their place courtesy of a 103 point thrashing of Adelaide that would see the end of Neil Craig as senior coach of the Crows.

Remarkably, the Saints had started the round 11 percent behind Essendon, but the two results orchestrated a 15 percent turnaround between the two sides that allowed St Kilda to move into eighth spot. Fremantle held seventh, while the Swans remained sixth with a comfortable 39 point win over the Bulldogs.

However, they remained six points behind West Coast, who also had a game in hand, to leave the fight for the double chance down to a race in five. Collingwood and Geelong continued on their merry way at the top of the ladder with the Magpies and Cats recording easy wins over Gold Coast and Richmond.