Tag: sumich

1990 Rewind: Exhausted Eagles Bow Out

~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

Travel Load Catches Up With Young Eagles

West Coast’s 1990 campaign fizzled out to a 63 point defeat against Essendon in the Preliminary Final, with the Bombers progressing to face Collingwood in the Grand Final.

Four consecutive matches at Waverley Park, and six interstate trips in a row, finally caught up with the young Eagles line-up, as they battled injury, illness and air strikes in the lead up to the match.

The Eagles were again forced to compromise their travel plans amid the ongoing national air strikes that had plagued much of their travelling over the previous six weeks.

West Coast ventured to Melbourne on a chartered flight, sharing the trip with the Perth Wildcats and Melbourne Tigers who were in the middle of their NBL Grand Final series. The trip required several stops along the way, and saw the three teams land in Melbourne on the Thursday – a day earlier than the Eagles’ usual schedule.

There were also concerns at the selection table.

Dwayne Lamb was unavailable, courtesy of a one week ban from the AFL tribunal, while nuggety midfielder Scott Watters was ruled out with a groin complaint.

Chris Mainwaring was struggling with a knee issue, Guy McKenna was racing the clock after injuring his arm late against the Demons and Laurie Keene was managing a groin injury. Craig Turley – who had been the Eagles best player over the prior fortnight – hadn’t trained all week due to the flu.

All four would take their place, but only Mainwaring would be a serviceable contributor.

Peter Melesso and Dean Turner were the two replacements for Lamb and Watters, with the selection of Turner somewhat of a surprise. Turner earned selection ahead of captain Steve Malaxos, who was left out of the side for a second week, as well as Don Pyke and Phil Narkle who had both been favoured to be included in the side.

Melesso was named after serving a five match suspension, but would then be a late withdrawal. Melesso took part in the warm-up ahead of the match, before being replaced by Todd Breman.

West Coast started the brighter of the two sides, but despite controlling possession struggled to find a way past half forward. Simon Madden, who had been heavily criticised during the week after a poor showing against the Magpies in the semi-final, was dominant both in the ruck and as the spare man in defence clogging up the space of the Eagle forwards.

Madden tallied 10 disposals and five marks for the term, as well as booting Essendon’s fourth goal of after a strong mark over Phil Scott in the goal square. The Eagles had just one major for the quarter; a solo effort from Mainwaring when he intercepted a defensive kick in the Eagles forward 50m area, before kicking truly on the run.

Stevan Jackson was busy early and finished with three goals

The quarter time deficit of 17 points was soon 43 as Essendon made West Coast pay for some sloppy play. Craig Turley started the rot when he dropped a simple mark in the middle of the ground, allowing the Bombers to regain possession with Darren Bewick finishing off a chain of play.

Alan Ezard then capitalised after the Eagles turned the ball over at half back before Simon Madden was able to boot his second of the match when John Worsfold was unable to handle the ball in defence.

Gary O’Donnell missed a golden opportunity, hitting the post running into an open goal, before Essendon caught a lucky break to boot their fourth major of the quarter. A scrappy kick forward by Derek Kickett eluded Phil Scott as he led Paul Salmon to the ball, allowing the Bomber full forward to hand off to Mark Harvey for a simple finish.

At this point, nothing was going right for West Coast.

Guy McKenna had copped a heavy hit that left him with a bloodied nose to along with the arm injury he was carrying, while Chris Mainwaring and Mark Harvey were involved in a brutal head clash that left both players on the ground for several minutes.

Finally, the Eagles found their second goal of the match. While they had been outplayed in most areas on the ground, the one spot they were winning was the centre clearances, even with Laurie Keene restricted.

Some good work out of the middle ended with Brett Heady steering through a second goal on his left foot from half forward, with the Eagles able to boot three more to give them an outside chance of victory.

However, a horrible handpass by Todd Breman deep in the Eagles defence gifted Ezard his second major of the quarter and the Bombers held a six goal lead at the main break.

Things only got harder straight after the restart when Karl Langdon was carted off after being knocked out cold in an accidental clash with Terry Daniher. Langdon attempted a diving mark, running back with the flight of the ball, with Daniher’s hip collecting Langdon in the head. With Keene also done for the day, the Eagles were without a bench, with a half to play and six goals behind.

Still, they refused to give up the fight. West Coast were the better side for much of the third term, with the play almost completely in their forward line. Essendon couldn’t find a way out of defence as West Coast continually pumped the ball into their forward 50, but they couldn’t make it count on the scoreboard.

Peter Sumich kicked the Eagles first goal, but then missed two more set shots, before Stevan Jackson hit the post from close range, and then Tony Begovich missed from directly in front after receiving a 50m penalty.

Mainwaring had a chance that failed to score, as did Michael Brennan, whose long range shot was marked on the line by Ezard. Sumich had a third chance that sailed out of bounds and for all their dominance, the Eagles had posted just 1.5 for the quarter.

Dean Turner then best exemplified the Eagles’ frustration when he cannoned into Ezard, well after the Bomber forward had taken a running shot on goal. Ezard’s effort missed, but the umpire awarded a second shot following Turner’s indiscretion, with Ezard able to boot his third goal and all but finish West Coast’s resistance in the match.

The Bombers added a further five goals in the final quarter to run out easy, albeit unconvincing, winners.

Malthouse admitted the heavy travel load had caught up with his side, but had nothing but praise, despite bowing out in penultimate week of the season.

“We looked and acted tired.”

“But I think the spirit was there to generate as much play as possible… it all caught up with them,” Malthouse said.

“The players showed enormous courage and fortitude… at no stage in six weeks of criss-crossing Australia was their a complaint. There was no sign of weakness during a severe test of the team’s character and competitiveness.”

Essendon coach Kevin Sheedy was happy enough with the performance, confident his side would bounce back from the thrashing by Collingwood the week before. “We were switched on early, and the players worked hard to get 18 wins this year and they did not want to let that slip.”

“I feel that will make us 10 percent better next week.”

Greg Anderson and Chris Mainwaring were both their respective sides’ best players, despite being opposed to each other on the wing for much of the afternoon. Anderson finished with 25 touches and booted 1.3, while Mainwaring had 19 disposals and booted a goal.

Terry Daniher and Mark Thompson also finished with 25 touches to lead the way at Essendon, while Tim Watson picked up 22 disposals and booted a goal. Simon Madden was another standout during the game with 21 possessions, 12 marks, 10 hitouts and two goals.

Alan Ezard and Mark Harvey each booted three goals.

At West Coast, Chris Lewis finished as the leading ball winner with 22 in his battle with Mark Thompson. Thompson was influential in the opening term, but Lewis had the better of the match-up over the remainder of the match despite Thompson still finding plenty of the ball. Lewis had been sublime through the second half of the season, with his consistent showing culminating in winning the club best and fairest, as well as being named in the All-Australian side (along with John Worsfold).

Chris Mainwaring was one of the Eagles’ best despite barely being able to see by games end

Dean Kemp picked up 21 touches and Brett Heady 20, as the two finished their impressive debut seasons with strong performances. Stevan Jackson offered plenty in the forward line with three goals from 14 disposals and six marks, while Peter Sumich would rue a wasteful day, finishing with 2.5.

Andrew Lockyer won his battle at centre half back on Paul Van der Haar, keeping the veteran Bomber to just nine disposals and two late goals. Craig Turley (17 disposals) and Guy McKenna (16) toiled hard despite their operating below their capacity.

The Eagles coach was openly proud of his side’s season, but the gains made in season 1990 were best summed up by opposing coach Kevin Sheedy. The Bombers coach – a former teammate of Malthouse’s at Richmond – praised Malthouse, saying he had added professionalism to the four year old club, while also lauding WA’s ‘sensational’ year.

Sheedy said playing four finals in a row was the equivalent of two finals series’ worth of experience, which would be ‘invaluable’.

“After physically and mentally going through it, the standard for West Coast has been set.”

The Eagles for their part had risen from a bit-part team out in the west, to one of premier clubs in the revamped competition in just one season. The addition of Malthouse had been an immediate success – and the board knew as much.

Days before Christmas, the Eagles announced that Malthouse had signed a three year extension to his initial contract, keeping him at the club until the end of 1994.

The ’90s had begun – as had the first Eagles dynasty.  

1990 Rewind: Eagles Exorcise Demons

~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

Historic First Finals Win For West Coast

West Coast set up a meeting with Essendon in the preliminary final after defeating Melbourne by five goals in the semi final.

Mick Malthouse’s drastic changes at the selection table paid off, as West Coast overcame a poor recent record against Melbourne to produce the clubs first ever win in a final.

One of those selections – Chris Waterman – produced a career best outing booting six goals across half forward.

Waterman was one of six changes for West Coast, with Eagles coach Mick Malthouse ruthlessly axing a quarter of the side that was demolished by Collingwood the week before in the Qualifying Final replay.

The most controversial omission was captain Steve Malaxos, who lost his place after a period of indifferent form. Malaxos had spent much of the previous two games against Collingwood on the bench, with Malthouse later saying the Eagles needed greater leg speed and running power on the wide expanses of Waverley Park.

Joining Malaxos out of the side were ruckman Dean Irving, who had been well beaten in both Collingwood matches, Troy Ugle, Craig McGrath, Murray Rance with a fractured jaw and Peter Wilson who would be a late withdrawal ahead of the game with a hamstring strain.

Phil Scott returned to the Eagles line-up, after being dropped on the eve of the finals, to partner Laurie Keene in the ruck, while Scott Watters returned after missing the replay with a knee injury. Stevan Jackson replaced McGrath up forward after ten goals with South Fremantle in the previous fortnight, while Waterman and Tony Begovich were added for their ability to run and spread.

When Wilson pulled out ahead of the game, Andrew Lockyer was called up, slotting into defence in place of the missing Rance. Guy McKenna had been in doubt after breaking a nose late in the loss to the Magpies, but held his spot, as did Mainwaring whose knee was becoming a week by week proposition.

Stevan Jackson returned to the Eagles side to be one of their best

Melbourne made no change when teams were announced but were soon to have their own late drama. Captain Garry Lyon was pulled from the side on the morning of the game after he suffered a corked thigh colliding with teammate Steven O’Dwyer the day before at training. Todd Viney was called up to the side.

Despite being without Lyon and midfielders Brian Wilson and Alan Johnson, the Demons were still hot favourites to progress to the preliminary final.

It took just 90 seconds for West Coast to show they weren’t going to just whimper away.

Kicking into the wind, the Eagles had two goals on the board – both to Chris Mainwaring – before Melbourne had even worked out their direct match-ups.

As well as bringing in a host of new players, Malthouse also moved his side around as he sought to catch the Demons off guard. Mainwaring started at half forward and his quick brace forced a shuffle of the Melbourne defence with Steven Stretch moved from the wing to replace Matthew Febey.

John Worsfold also started forward, as did Chris Lewis as the Eagles looked to avoid an early tag. Lewis still had Stephen Newport for company, but was influential early as West Coast established an important 13 point lead at quarter time.

Andrew Obst had been instrumental in Melbourne’s win over the Eagles in Perth several weeks earlier and Malthouse wasn’t keen on letting the midfielder run unattended again. Guy McKenna shifted into the midfield in a run-with role, holding Obst to just 12 disposals for the game.

Laurie Keene led the ruck, with Phil Scott taking the resting ruckman in the back pocket, while Andrew Lockyer had first crack at Darren Bennett.

The Demons tried to repeat the physical approach that had seen them defeat West Coast twice during the regular season, but the Eagles kept their focus on the ball.

The 13 point advantage exploded to 45 points by the main break, with the Eagles booting six goals to none with the wind, and the match was as good as done.

Melbourne outscored the Eagles in the second half, but West Coast were never in danger of giving up their spot in the Grand Final playoff.

West Coast would have to get past Essendon if they were to make their first ever Grand Final, after the Bombers were comprehensively beaten by Collingwood in the other semi-final.

Kevin Sheedy denied the Bombers would be affected by the additional layoff because of the drawn Qualifying Final leading into the match, but they appeared sluggish going on to lose by 63 points. The Magpies led by 12 points at half time, but ten goals to two after half time saw Collingwood qualify for their first premiership decider in nine years.

While West Coast could feel satisfied with the history-making first ever finals win in the clubs history, there were concerns to come out of the five goal win.

Scott Watters had arguably been the Eagles’ best player in the first half, but spent the entire second half on the bench with a groin complaint. Guy McKenna suffered a suspected broken arm after clashing with Earl Spalding in the dying minutes of the game and three Eagles wound up on report from separate incidents in the game.

Chris Lewis was placed on report for charging Graeme Yeats and Stevan Jackson was reported for striking Jim Stynes. Both players would get off at the tribunal during the week, but Dwayne Lamb wasn’t so fortunate.

The Eagles tagger was also charged for reporting Stynes, copping a one week ban. Lamb, and many of the other Eagles, were still seeking retribution from the last match between the two sides which saw Stynes break Lamb’s arm with an attempted soccer off the ground.

The Eagles gave it to Stynes, every chance they could, and it appeared to work as Keene controlled the stoppages and provided plenty of attacking run off Stynes around the ground.

The move appeared to work with Melbourne unable to get any direction or structure on the field with their captain missing and their ruckman ineffective.

At the feet of Keene, Craig Turley, Dean Kemp and David Hart had plenty of the ball as they overwhelmed their Demons counterparts. For the second week in a row Turley was one of the best for West Coast, revelling in the centreman role in the absence of Malaxos.

Turley finished with 26 disposals, one behind Mainwaring who had a team high 27 possessions to go with his two goals at the start of the match. Hart, Kemp and Brett Heady all tallied 21 while Keene himself finished with 23 touches, four marks and ten hit-outs.

Scott Watters was one of the best for West Coast but finished on the bench injured

Up forward, the change in dynamic did wonders with West Coast kicking their highest score since round 19. Waterman was the surprise packet with six goals from 17 disposals and nine marks, while Peter Sumich booted four and Stevan Jackson three, the trio combining for 13 of the Eagles’ 19 goals.

Sumich and Jackson also each booted five behinds, with Jackson also gathering 21 disposals and five marks – highlighting the dominance of the Eagles’ tall forwards.

The Demons had few players who shone, with Simon Eishold and Greg Healy the leading ball winners with 20 disposals. Stephen Newport gathered 16 disposals and seven marks after starting in a tagging role on Chris Lewis. Newport was then replaced by Glenn Lovett, but Lewis had the better of both players as his blistering second half of the season continued.

Rod Grinter booted four last quarter goals when he was shifted forward, with Ricky Jackson, Graeme Yeats and Darren Bennett each kicking two.

Demons coach John Northey called his side’s performance ‘pathetic’, with Melbourne unable to live up to their favouritism billing heading into the match. “In finals football, you have to find something extra all the time, and our players weren’t prepared to do it.”

Northey believed that the underdog status had worked in the Eagles’ favour, after two testing weeks against the Magpies.

“When everyone is kicking us in the guts, we have something to prove, but as soon as we become favourites in something, we have always faltered, and not just once, it has happened many, many times,” expressed a frustrated Northey.

 For Mick Malthouse, the performance was justification for their season and followed his earlier comments the week before that West Coast would bounce back. “I think a lot of people underestimated the fighting spirit of this group.”

“We didn’t make the finals series for the sake of making the finals series.”

Malthouse also believed the first ever finals win would be a great fillip for his side as they continued their push for a maiden flag.

“It (a finals win) is fantastic for the players… this year we have won in Sydney for the first time, the MCG for the first time. These are all little hurdles all along that are being looked at by the players.”

The Eagles coach also denied it was a risk making the mass number of changes ahead of the game, with many of the inclusions having a strong say in the final result.

“If it hadn’t come off, I suppose it may have been the biggest gamble of my coaching career,” Malthouse wryly admitted.

1990 Rewind: Not Done Yet

~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

Malthouse Declares Eagles Will Bounce Back From Replay Thrashing

Eagles coach Mick Malthouse boldly declared his side’s season wouldn’t end in the following weeks semi-final, after succumbing to Collingwood in the qualifying final replay.

West Coast were blown out of the game in the opening term and apart from a ten minute period late in the third quarter, never appeared likely to work their way back into the game.

After the match, Malthouse refused to concede the Eagles would struggle to get past Melbourne in the semi-final, despite needing to return to Waverley Park for a fourth straight week. The Demons had enjoyed the luxury of the week off as West Coast and Collingwood did battle for a second consecutive week.

“The players have a history of character and we have rebounded before. I am confident of beating Melbourne.”

The Eagles though were sluggish as the travel back and forth from Perth appeared to have taken its toll.

West Coast made two changes from the drawn match, with Chris Waterman dropped and Scott Watters unable to take his place after failing a fitness test on the morning of the match. Peter Wilson was recalled from a fractured cheekbone suffered against the Tigers in Round 19, with Troy Ugle the late inclusion for Watters.

Despite concerns over an ongoing knee injury, Chris Mainwaring held his spot on the wing. Steve Malaxos was another who held his spot despite growing speculation over his position in the side.

Collingwood also made two changes with forwards Craig Starcevich and Brian Taylor both dropped. Despite Leigh Matthews’ claims during the week that the Magpies would need a more fleet-footed side, like-for-like players Michael Christian and Denis Banks were the players selected in their place.

Taylor, in particular, could feel aggrieved for his omission after his crucial last quarter involvement saw him kick two goals as the Magpies salvaged a draw. After being left out of the side, the burly full forward announced he would retire at seasons end.

West Coast lined up much like they had the week before, but Leigh Matthews threw his Magpies’ side around to unhinge many of the Eagles’ match ups. James Manson was preferred in the ruck ahead of Damien Monkhorst, regular defender Gavin Crosisca played across half forward and Mick McGuane was recast as a tagger on Chris Lewis.

The Magpies also went small up forward with Gavin Brown and Peter Daicos operating out of the goal square, dragging running defender Guy McKenna to the last line.

Steve Malaxos started in the middle opposed to Collingwood captain Tony Shaw while David Hart also started in the middle with the task of running with Tony Francis.

The match started fiercely when Peter Sumich opened the scoring. Paul Peos’ shot on goal faded towards the goal line with the full forward able to mark over two Collingwood defenders. From the tight angle, Sumich ran around and kicked the Eagles’ first major, but was felled after snapping the goal by Magpie Michael Christian.

Christian was reported for his late hit as a melee involving 20 players broke out in the Eagles forward line. Spotfires continued to erupt around the ground, but it would be Collingwood who would settle into the game better.

The Magpies booted eight of the next nine goals in the quarter, opening up a six goal lead.

And it was the work of Manson in the ruck, who did much of the damage. The lanky ruckman had the better of Dean Irving at the tap, but also exposed the Eagles ruckman around the ground.

With Collingwood benefitting from the breeze in the opening quarter, Irving stationed himself in the Eagles defence. However, Manson enjoyed the freedom through the centre of the ground, running forward to boot two goals in the term, while also having a hand in many of the Magpies other scoring chains.

Gavin Brown and Tony Francis also kicked two majors for the quarter as Collingwood swiftly moved the ball around the ground. Peter Daicos and Darren Millane also hit the scoreboard, with Peter Sumich adding a second goal for West Coast.

The Eagles started strongly in the second term, taking control at the stoppages in the centre square. Laurie Keene took over in the ruck as the Eagles claimed the first four centre clearances. Karl Langdon opened the scoring before Mick McGuane answered after taking a strong mark as he is crunched by John Worsfold and David Hart.

Laurie Keene responded for West Coast, but Collingwood finished the term stronger. Craig Kelly had been shifted forward after starting in defence on Craig McGrath, kicking truly after out-marking Michael Brennan and Brett Heady. Peter Daicos added a second and Gavin Crosisca finished off an impressive first half with a goal that saw Collingwood’s lead reach 49 points at the major break.

Matthews continued to shuffle his players around, preventing West Coast to find a rhythm in the game. Kelly went back to defence in the third term, as did Denis Banks and Shane Morwood, with Matthews dictating the match ups in the battle of the coaches box.

For West Coast, too many players struggled to get into the game. Chris Lewis was blanketed by McGuane, with Malthouse moving the dynamic midfielder into the forward line in a bid to shake the tag. Peter Wilson struggled to handle the pace of the final in his first game in six weeks and the Eagles forward line was virtually non-existent.

Craig Turley was one of the few good players for West Coast

Little much changed to start the third term, with Daicos and Brown each booting their third goals of the match to stretch the Magpies’ lead to a game high 60 points. But with Collingwood coasting to victory, West Coast roared back into the contest.

Ron McKeown, who had had the better of Sumich, limped off with a corked thigh which unsettled the Magpie backline. Michael Christian had been resolute across half back, mainly playing loose in defence, but was forced to mind Sumich.

The Eagles slammed on five goals in eight minutes to put the pro-Collingwood crowd on edge.

Trailing by 30 points with a quarter to play, Peter Sumich had a golden opportunity in the opening seconds of the final term to continue the Eagles momentum.

But as had been the case the week before, Sumich failed to capitalise. Leading new opponent Shane Morwood back to the goal square, Sumich valiantly flailed his left leg at an awkwardly bouncing ball, failing to make even the slightest contact that would have brought West Coast within 24 points.

Instead, Gavin Brown marked a torpedo effort from Peter Daicos at the top of the goal square to steady the Magpies. Collingwood booted the only five goals of the last quarter to run out comfortable 59 point winners – ultimately a fair margin between the two teams on the day.

The result marked the Magpies first finals win since 1984 and the first victory in a final for coach Leigh Matthews. “Most definitely a relief. We’re playing for a Grand Final spot whereas we could have been playing for survival,” a happy Matthews said after the game.

Conversely, a despondent Malthouse reflected on the missed opportunity of the week before.

“Last week was there to be won – I’m a realist.”

“A lot of our players didn’t reach the level they did last week, but it’s been a magnificent experience so far for the players. We always looked second to the ball… and that is a state of mind.”

While acknowledging that his players looked tired, the Eagles coach maintained faith that his side would bounce back against the Demons.

“They (finals) don’t stay the same, they don’t decrease, they always get tougher, week in, week out, and these players have now experienced the intensity of two in a row.”

The difference between the two sides proved to be the spread of contributors as Collingwood had a greater share of the workload. Michael Christian finished as the leading ball winner for the Magpies with 24 disposals and eight marks, while midfielder Scott Russell and wingman Graeme Wright were the next best with 23.

All up, Collingwood had ten players hit the scoreboard with Daicos and Brown the best of those with four each.

Tony Shaw had the better of Steve Malaxos in their individual duel, as did Tony Francis opposed to David Hart. Denis Banks kept Karl Langdon to just ten disposals and a goal and Mick Gayfer provided plenty of run alongside Christian at half back.

For West Coast, only a handful could match the output of the week before. Craig Turley was arguably the Eagles’ best collecting 22 disposals and kicking a goal and winning his contest with Doug Barwick. Laurie Keene was influential when he replaced Dean Irving in the ruck with 21 disposals, 12 hit-outs and two goals. Keene and Sumich (four goals) were the only multiple goal scorers for West Coast.

Dwayne Lamb finished with 26 touches to lead the disposal getters for West Coast, but couldn’t quell the impact of Scott Russell for the Magpies, while Lewis toiled through the game to pick up 20 touches playing between half forward and the midfield.

The double chance had turned into a triple chance, but West Coast now found their season on the line with the Demons waiting.

1990 Rewind: Finals Chaos As Eagles, Magpies Draw

~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

Sumich Shoots Wide On Siren

West Coast and Collingwood opened the 1990 finals series with a dramatic draw in the Qualifying Final, flipping the entire finals series on its head.

Peter Sumich had the chance to win the game in the dying seconds, but his missed set shot from close range in the left forward pocket, left the two teams matched on 13.12 (90) as the final siren rang.

The result – the first draw in a final since the 1977 Grand Final – was set to throw the finals series into disarray, with the Eagles and Magpies due to return to Waverley Park the following weekend to determine who would progress to the first semi-final to tackle the Bombers.

Melbourne were awaiting the loser of the replayed match, after they knocked reigning premiers Hawthorn out of the premiership race with a nine-point win in front of nearly 75,000 fans at the MCG.

The Demons now also had the added benefit of a week off ahead of the second semi-final after winning through the elimination final. Conversely, Essendon – who had earned the week off in the first week of the finals for finishing top at the end of the home-and-away season – were now facing a second straight week off, complicating their preparations for their first final.

Essendon coach Kevin Sheedy dismissed suggestions the protracted series would work against the Bombers, despite the prospect of over three weeks between their final round match against the Saints and the first semi-final. “We have played 22 home and away games this year, four Fosters Cup games and eight practice matches. I don’t think we need to worry about fitness.”

While the AFL were estimating an additional $800,000 would be generated from the extra match to be played, they were also forced to busily reschedule many of the planned events over the coming month. The Grand Final was now set to be played a week later on October 6, however the date for the Brownlow medal wasn’t expected to change.

The Magpies were heavy favourites heading into the match, off the back of their two largest wins of the season in the final two rounds. The Magpies took in an unchanged side from the win over North Melbourne, despite a couple of key injury concerns. 

Darren Millane stayed in the side despite fracturing a thumb against the Kangaroos, as did ruckman James Manson who trained lightly leading up to the match due to an ongoing groin issue. The Magpies also had Denis Banks and Shane Kerrison available to return from injury, although neither was recalled for the clash against the Eagles.

Full-forward Brian Taylor also kept his spot, despite an indifferent two seasons at the club. Taylor had managed just one game in the back half of 1989 due to a knee injury (coincidentally against the Eagles) and had featured in just five further matches in 1990, returning to the side in round 21 against Fitzroy.

The Eagles made just one change with Dean Irving returning after being dropped for the final round match against Geelong. Controversially, fellow ruckman Phil Scott was the one to make way after playing all 22 games during the home-and-away season.

For Mick Malthouse, it was a heart-wrenching decision. “This was the toughest decision I have made in seven years of coaching.”

“Phil accepted the decision like the professional sportsman that he is.”

Craig Turley also held his place despite concerns over a groin problem. West Coast were considered outsiders – namely by the Victorian media – with ten players playing in their first final. The Eagles were also playing only their third game ever in club history at Waverley Park; their other two appearances had both resulted in losses.

Steve Malaxos won the toss and sent his side the way of the breeze in the opening term, but the more experienced Magpies were able to settle first. Taylor had an early chance in the game, hitting the post with his first shot, before sending his second effort on goal out of bounds on the full.

His presence on the game forced an early positional change in the match, with Murray Rance and Michael Brennan swapping. The larger Rance headed to the goal square to match on Taylor, with Brennan shifting to centre half back on Craig Starcevich.

Dean Irving was stationed as a loose man in defence as Collingwood continued to push the ball forward, but while West Coast were able to limit the damage on the scoreboard early, the Magpies’ opposing ruckman Damien Monkhorst was allowed to dictate play and provide the link playing loose through the middle of the ground.

Monkhorst would be involved in the chain that delivered Collingwood the opening goal of the game. Chris Mainwaring was caught holding the ball across half forward, by opponent Mick McGuane, with Collingwood able to transition quickly to the other end of the ground.

Graeme Wright received the handpass from Monkhorst through the centre square, and kicked inside forward 50, looking for Taylor. However, Peter Daicos was able to read the spoil from Rance and after a handpass exchange with Starcevich, Daicos found some space to slot the important first major.

Gavin Brown added a second after being held by Guy McKenna in a marking contest, before West Coast worked their way into the game. Laurie Keene wobbled through the Eagles’ first on the run, before Brett Heady made it two goals in succession.

Brown added a second for the quarter, and third for the match for the Magpies, but his effort was cancelled out by Peter Sumich from long range leaving West Coast five points behind at the first change.

Mick McGuane was the clear standout at quarter time, picking up 16 disposals on the wing for the term opposed to Chris Mainwaring. His red hot start continued into the second term when an early shot on goal cannoned into the post. The Magpies managed several more efforts without success, before Sumich swung the game back in favour of West Coast.

Sumich goaled twice from long range to draw the Eagles level, before Karl Langdon sent through his own long bomb from beyond the arc to put West Coast in front.

However, that only seemed to spark the Magpies into gear.

Brian Taylor was dragged to the bench and the more mobile Craig Starcevich became the prime target up forward. Peter Daicos continued to present a threat, as did Gavin Brown who was now operating out of the goal square.

The Magpies booted the final three goals of the term to open up a 12 point lead at the main break. Collingwood were also guilty of wasting their chances on goal, having had seven more scoring shots for the half than West Coast.

Both coaches made moves to start the second half, as they looked for the all-important edge in the match. Ron McKeown replaced Craig Kelly at full back on Peter Sumich and Worsfold took Daicos in the Eagles defensive half.

And as the match grew in intensity, so did the sublime skills of its participants.

Dean Kemp drew the Eagles within a kick with a pinpoint goal from the pocket, before Daicos responded with a 40 metre snap. Peter Sumich add his fourth of the match, again from long range, and Chris Waterman kicked truly after being found on his own in the forward pocket, to see the Eagles reach parity.

West Coast were now in control of the game, led by Dwayne Lamb who gathered 12 possessions for the quarter, and Scott Watters, who had nine. James Manson put the Magpies back in front against the run of play after a sloppy turnover in defence, but the Eagles continued to generate opportunities.

Brett Heady, Chris Mainwaring and Dwayne Lamb all missed before Chris Lewis typified the class of the game, with a truly outrageous goal to put the Eagles back in front.

Ron McKeown was captured in defence by Kemp, with the ball spilling towards the boundary line where Lewis was able to swoop, gather, brush off the tackling attempt from Scott Russell before snapping through an incredible goal on his non-preferred foot in amongst a nest of Magpies.

Further adding to the difficulty of Lewis’ effort, Lewis had also lost his footing during the play, stranded on his knees before being able to lift back to his feet and kick an important goal for the Eagles.

Lewis had been instrumental in the second quarter in keeping West Coast in touch with Collingwood as they built an early advantage and now, as the match closed in on three-quarter time, the Eagles were the ones with all of the momentum.

Chris Lewis continued his excellent form from the second half of the season in the drawn final

Heady would miss a chance after some clever play by Lewis at half forward, where he was able to pluck the ball away just as Collingwood were set to clear from defence, before Heady and Sumich would then clash competing for the same mark. Dwayne Lamb would also miss a chance to get a shot on goal after fumbling at the top of the goal square.

A swift chain of passes from defence ended with Doug Barwick kicking truly to give Collingwood an unlikely two point lead, against the run of play, with a quarter to play.

The two point deficit became a ten point lead for West Coast early in the final quarter after Heady and Lewis each booted majors in quick succession. The Eagles runners – the likes of Watters, Lamb, Chris Mainwaring and Guy McKenna – had controlled the tempo of the game since half-time and the Magpies were struggling to keep pace.

Mick McGuane had faded out of the game after his blistering first quarter and found himself on the pine, while James Manson had been sent from attack to defence to quell Karl Langdon who had been in everything during the third term.

Trailing, Leigh Matthews reinstated Brian Taylor to the field after spending the second and third terms on the bench and the move paid immediate dividends. Taylor was able to claim a diving mark in front of Murray Rance, and goal, to reduce the Eagles lead to four points.

A few minutes later, Taylor added a second after Rance caught him high in a marking contest, and Collingwood had worked their way back into the lead.

The Magpies appeared to have done away with the Eagles challenge when Peter Daicos extended their lead with an effort that managed to top Lewis’ freakish effort in the previous term.

The Eagles attempt to exit their defensive 50m arc came unstuck when Guy McKenna missed John Worsfold with a pass, after a strong mark in the Magpies’ goal square. Gavin Brown was able to win the loose ball back near the boundary line, feeding a handpass up the line to Darren Millane, who instantly handpassed over his shoulder to Daicos deep in the forward pocket.

With the outside of his right boot, from the wrong pocket, Daicos magically worked the ball to land at the feet of the goal umpire and extend the Magpies’ lead out to eight points with just five minutes remaining.

West Coast though continued to push.

A desperate effort from Steve Malaxos across half forward prevented Collingwood from clearing out of defence, with Langdon able to snap truly from a boundary throw-in. Waterman dragged a shot on goal from deep in the pocket, reducing Collingwood’s lead to a solitary point before the final last play that had the game in the balance.

Chris Mainwaring twice failed to find an Eagles target in the forward half before Darren Millane attempted to clear out of defence. However, Eagles runner Rob Wiley inadvertently kept the ball in the Eagles forward line when he got in the way of Millane’s handpass resulting in a boundary throw in.

Langdon won the ball from Keene at the restart with his attempt on goal floating across the face into the opposite pocket where Sumich was able to mark over his shoulder. His final kick would become instantly folklore.

Peter Sumich laments his late miss

All up, the lead changed eight times during the match, and while the teams may not have been separated at the completion of four quarters, the same couldn’t be said for the attitude of the two coaches.

While Leigh Matthews was relieved to have a second chance at the second chance, his counterpart in Malthouse was left ruing the missed opportunity.

“We didn’t make the most of the opportunities. When the game was there to be won, we didn’t grab it.”

Malthouse expressed frustration that West Coast couldn’t take advantage of the lead they built during the final quarter and run out to win the game. “I feel bitterly disappointed. We didn’t achieve what we came here to achieve.”

The Eagles coach was also unwilling to accept much of the post-match praise from the Victorian media, who joined in with Matthews’ assessment that the Eagles were stronger contenders for the flag than many scribes had suggested.

“They were always going to play better than the public perception of them – that almost inevitably is the case,” Matthews said.

“It was never going to be easy. We didn’t think we played well, but we live to fight another day and that’s the way we are looking at it.”

The Collingwood coach refused to admit they were fortunate to make it out with a draw, but said they were ‘thankful’ to get another crack. “With a draw you tend to be disappointed because you haven’t won – until you tell yourself you haven’t lost either.”

“We feel quite positive about having another chance.”

The ramifications of the draw would lead the AFL to change how drawn matches were decided, with the Commission voting to introduce two five-minute periods of extra time for all finals, other than the Grand Final.

For now though, West Coast and Collingwood had a week to prepare to do it all again and Malthouse had one message for those who had decided to jump on the Eagles bandwagon.

“Do us a favour and write us off,” Malthouse declared.

“Maybe they (the media) have underestimated the fierceness and willingness to contest. We showed today what we are capable of doing.”

“As far as I’m concerned it’s half time in the match. It’s a 14-day game.”

1990 Rewind: Eagles Lock In Double Chance

~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

West Coast Hold Third With Final Quarter Fightback

As the clock ticked into time-on of the third quarter at Kardinia Park, the Eagles’ double chance hopes looked shot.

A goal to Trevor Poole had extended Geelong’s lead out to 31 points over a sluggish West Coast side that had been unable to match the Cats throughout the afternoon. Elsewhere, results were not favouring the Eagles.

With the Magpies thrashing North Melbourne and the Demons holding a handy advantage heading towards three quarter time over the Hawks, West Coast were poised to drop to fourth to face reigning premiers Hawthorn in an elimination final in the first week of the finals.

But the Eagles of 1990 have developed the steely resolve of their back-pocket coach and by game’s end, West Coast were celebrating another incredible win in the clubs short history.

Goals to Craig McGrath, Peter Sumich and Chris Waterman in the final six minutes leading into three-quarter time reduced the margin to 18 points, to give West Coast hope and put the stutters into the Cats and their fans.

Then Brett Heady – who had been well beaten by Geelong’s best player on the afternoon, Ken Hinkley – bobbed up to kick two quick goals to start the final term when Hinkley was forced off the ground with injury.

Karl Langdon also added a brace of goals in the final term as West Coast steamrolled the home side five goals to one, securing a seven point victory.

And it was a returning big man who seemed to be the catalyst for the Eagles comeback.

Laurie Keene hadn’t been seen at AFL level since Round 2 1989 as he battled knee and lower leg complaints but was named after stringing together a number of games with Subiaco. Keene had travelled with the squad to Brisbane the week before and was promoted to the senior side after Mick Malthouse lost patience with the ruck pairing of Phil Scott and Dean Irving.

Scott held his place but Irving was omitted from the team that defeated Brisbane, along with Phil Narkle and Dean Turner. Joining Keene into the team were Paul Peos, who was selected for his first match since suffering a knee injury in round 3, and Dwayne Lamb who made a surprise return just two weeks after breaking his forearm.

Lamb took to the field with an arm brace and was assigned the job of minding Cats centreman Paul Couch. Scott started in the ruck, with Keene forward and John Worsfold was matched on dangerous Cats forward Gary Ablett.

Geelong had endured a horror season, with just eight wins for the season and would have been excused for having their minds on Mad Monday, rather than the clash with the Eagles. But it was Geelong who started the game like there was something on the line.

Stoneham controlled the ruck, allowing the likes of Neville Bruns and Garry Hocking to drive Geelong forward where Ablett was all over Worsfold. The Geelong forward had six shots on goal in the first quarter alone, but was wasteful with 2.3 and one that sailed out of bounds.

The Cats had only a four point lead at quarter time to show for their early dominance, but they were able to grow their lead over the next two terms with Ken Hinkley controlling the play at half back and the Malekellis brothers joining Hocking and Bruns in winning plenty of the ball through the middle.

Malthouse persisted with Worsfold on Ablett and Lamb had the better of his duel with Couch, but many other Eagles struggled to work their way into the game. Steve Malaxos, David Hart, Dean Kemp and Craig Turley had limited impact in the game, while up forward Peter Sumich was well held by novice Cats defender Mark Neeld.

Sumich had limped off with a hamstring concern the week before against the Bears, but played against Geelong with Malthouse adamant during the week that there was nothing wrong with the Eagle spearhead.

It took the move of Keene into the ruck to swing the match.

Keene took over from Phil Scott in the ruck midway through the third term and his influence at the stoppages was immediate. Chris Lewis and Scott Watters were able to gain an upper hand at the clearances and the Eagles started to generate meaningful forward entries.

Scott Watters produced his best game of the season against the Cats

The Eagles would finish with eight of the last ten goals in the match, confirming third spot – the position they had held on the ladder since round 14 – and were set for the clubs’ second ever final against Collingwood.

The win to West Coast said as much as the loss did about Geelong.

For the second week in a row, the Cats had lost at home late in the game after giving up a decisive lead. The Cats had capitulated on multiple occasions during the season and this match was the fifth time instance where Geelong had lost despite having more scoring shots.

For Geelong, the writing on the wall for season 1990 may have been in the humiliating 115 point round one loss to Hawthorn, in the Grand Final replay.

Cats coach Malcolm Blight was pointed in his criticism of the football club. “I’m starting to think that if a side gets close to us, history shows they can beat us.”

“That’s going to be the biggest thing for the Geelong Football Club to overcome.”

The return of Keene also added a new element to the West Coast side, with Blight stating ‘he gave the Eagles a look they haven’t had all year’.

Chris Lewis was again one of the best for West Coast with 20 touches and two goals, while Dwayne Lamb marked his remarkable return with a team high 26 disposals. Lamb also nullified the influence of Paul Couch, with Blight dragging his Brownlow medallist from the ground during the third term.

Scott Watters recorded his highest possession count for the season with 23 and had appeared to time his claim for a senior spot to perfection, having returned to the league side the week before against Brisbane.

Chris Mainwaring worked his way into the game with 24 disposals and Paul Peos also produced a strong showing in his return from injury with 22 touches on the wing.

Neville Bruns was a four-quarter performer for the Cats with 24 kicks and 11 handpasses and Ken Hinkley was the Cats’ best before he hobbled off early in the final term, having accumulated 30 disposals and nine marks.

Garry Hocking picked up 24 touches, Barry Stoneham collected 20 disposals and nine marks in his battle with Phil Scott and then Keene in the ruck, while Gary Ablett was the prime forward in the match, booting 6.5 from 15 disposals.

All spots were up for grabs heading into the final round, but with West Coast overcoming the Cats, there were no changes to the final make-up of the top five.

Essendon secured the minor premiership with a 35 point win over the Saints, who were once again without Tony Lockett. The Bombers trailed at half-time, but a seven-goal final term got the Bombers the win. The match was most notable for the appearance of all four Daniher brothers in the same team; the first time a quartet of brothers played together in the same team.

Collingwood did it easy over North Melbourne, coasting to an 89 point win to finish second on the ladder. With the result determined by half-time, most of the interest surrounded whether Kangaroos full forward and Coleman medal incumbent John Longmire could reach 100 goals for the season.

Longmire had started the match with 96 goals for the season, but his accuracy in front of goal deserted him, returning an inaccurate 2.8 to fall two goals short of the ton.

Melbourne and Hawthorn stayed in fourth and fifth with the Demons holding to a 12 point win, upsetting Hawks captain Michael Tuck’s record-breaking 404th AFL game. The Demons led by 39 points at three-quarter time, but had to withstand a fightback from the Hawks in the final term. The result meant that the two teams were set to play again the following week in the elimination final.

Eagles coach Mick Malthouse acknowledged the achievement of rebounding from a poor 1989 season to reaching finals in 1990, but declared his side would have much to improve on ahead of the Magpies.

Malthouse was also confident that Keene had put the ongoing injury issues of the past 18 months behind him, and could be an important cog in West Coast’s finals campaign.

1990 Rewind: Lewis Magic Lifts West Coast

~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

Eagles Get Necessary Win In Penultimate Round

In a game that failed to reach great heights, West Coast got the four points against the Brisbane Bears to keep their hold on third place, with just one regular-season game left.

The Eagles were solid, rather than spectacular in the win, opening up a 20 point lead at the first change before going on to a 41 point result in front of just 7,286 fans at Carrara.

And while those that did come to the ground would have seen the match play out as expected between a team vying for the double chance and another team near the foot of the ladder, they were treated to one of the great individual performances of the year.

Chris Lewis had endured a frustrating start to the season when a hamstring injury and then an ankle problem restricted the midfielder/forward to just one quarter in the opening five games.

A fortnight with WAFL club Claremont built some match fitness before Lewis returned to the Eagles side, hitting his stride in the second half of the season. In ten matches from round 11, Lewis averaged 23 disposals per game and booted 15 goals as West Coast consolidated their spot in the top five.

Against the Bears in Round 21, Lewis put in a career best performance.

Running through the midfield, Lewis collected 28 kicks, 10 handballs, seven marks and booted three goals in a clear best on ground display. The Bears had no answer to the masterful showing from Lewis, who displayed his skills both in the stoppage and out in space and had a hand in creating a number of scoring opportunities.

The Eagles made a host of changes to the side that played the Bears, following their loss to the Demons a week earlier. Dwayne Lamb was forced out with a broken arm and Peter Melesso commenced his five-week suspension for stomping. The casualties from the defeat were Troy Ugle, Tony Begovich and Geoff Miles.

Into the West Coast line up were John Worsfold, who returned from serving a two week ban, Craig McGrath who was a late withdrawal the week before, as well as Scott Watters, Dean Turner and Murray Rance who forced his way into the side after six weeks in the WAFL.

The Bears made just two changes with Chris O’Sullivan and Brad Rowe replacing dropped pair Ray Windsor and Shaun Hart.

Laurie Keene made the trip with the Eagles squad as the travelling emergency, with Malthouse remaining cagey over whether the ruckman would make his return from injury. Keene had been sidelined since the second match of 1989 and even Bears coach Norm Dare predicted pre-match that Keene would be included in the Eagles side.

“I can’t believe Keene would come all this way and not play.”

Keene wasn’t a late inclusion with Malthouse giving the pairing of Dean Irving and Phil Scott a chance to bounce back from the beating they copped against Jim Stynes the week before.

And while both lowered their colours to ex-Eagle Alex Ishchenko, it mattered little as Lewis led the strong showing from the West Coast midfield. David Hart and Stephen Malaxos complemented the silky skills of Lewis with the inside grunt, while Craig Turley and Chris Mainwaring provided the linking run on the wings.

Up forward, Peter Sumich booted four goals, taking his total to 73 for the season, equalling the club record set by Ross Glendinning in 1988. However, Sumich would finish the afternoon on the bench. In only his second game back from missing a month with a hamstring, Sumich once again felt a twinge with the Eagles medical staff taking no chances on their spearhead.

Chris Lewis was sublime for the Eagles against Brisbane

For Malthouse, the defensive effort was the most pleasing aspect, having conceded 100 points in each of the previous two games.

“The idea was to restrict their scoring, which is something we’ve not done in the last two weeks. The Bears only got eight goals – that’s exactly the result we wanted.”

“They had some good runners but we were able to shut them down and we broke through their defence enough times to kick a winning score.”

Pleased with the performance of his defence, Malthouse had special praise for the returning Rance who restricted Bears full-forward Roger Merrett to just nine disposals and a goal.

“It was just about his (Rance) best game this year. Not because of how many kicks he got, but because of who he was playing on and the way he handled himself under pressure.” Malthouse went on to say it was the best game Rance had played at the club.

Rance himself tallied 15 disposals and seven marks to finish as one of the best for West Coast. David Hart relished not having a tag for the match to gather 31 disposals through the middle, while Steve Malaxos picked up 29 touches.

Guy McKenna had 25 disposals off half back, while Craig McGrath provided the perfect foil for Sumich in the forward line with 21 touches, nine marks and 2.3. Chris Waterman – who held his spot after being a late inclusion the week before – was also one of the Eagles’ best with 19 possessions, nine marks and a goal.

Mark Withers was the leading disposal winner for the Bears with 27, while David Bain and Scott McIvor each picked up 26 touches. With the Bears’ key forwards well held by the tight West Coast defence, only Michael Richardson and Matthew Campbell finished as multiple goal scorers with two each.

Bears coach Norm Dare admitted he was flat after the match believing many of his players already had their eye on the end of the season. The Bears were relegated to last on the ladder and were set for the wooden spoon, after Sydney stunned the Cats by two points at Kardinia Park.

The win kept West Coast in third, with all of the finals incumbents registering wins in the penultimate round of the regular season. Essendon stayed top, despite being jumped by Footscray. The Bulldogs opened up a four goal lead at the first change, but the Bombers had hit the front by half-time, before rolling away to a 24 point win.

That kept the Bombers a win ahead at the top of the ladder, with Collingwood putting in the most impressive performance from the top five, thrashing Fitzroy by 86 points. The Demons and Hawks kept their own double chance hopes alive with efficient wins over Richmond and Carlton.

Melbourne broke free of the Tigers with a five goal second quarter, to run out steady 36 point winners, while Jason Dunstall kicked six goals for the Hawks in their 31 point win over the Blues.

While West Coast mostly tailored through their win against the Bears, the performance wasn’t a concern for Eagles coach Mick Malthouse, pointing out the eight hour trip from Perth to the Gold Coast was an acceptable factor.

The air strike that had debilitated much of the national travel system meant West Coast had to make stops in Adelaide and then Sydney, before eventually reaching their destination in Queensland. Conditions at the ground were also tough with hot, blustery winds greeting the teams at Carrara.

“Fatigue was a big factor. It’s a long journey, it’s a big ground and we haven’t played in that sort of heat for a long time.”

“A win, is a win, is a win – and that’s all it was.”

1990 Rewind: Eagles Fail Demons Challenge… Again

~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

Final Five Set, But Double Chance Remains Up For Grabs

West Coast missed out on securing the double chance in the finals when they lost to Melbourne in a heated encounter in front of a packed house at Subiaco Oval.

The Demons ended the Eagles’ 15-game winning streak at home – stretching back to round 11, 1989 – with a comprehensive 36 point win.

A win would have pushed the Eagles two games clear of the fourth-placed Demons, with two rounds to play, but the race to finish in the top three and secure the double chance in the opening week of the finals was set to be decided over the final two weeks of the home and away season.

Further compounding the loss, West Coast could have climbed to equal top of the ladder after Essendon and Collingwood both suffered defeats 24 hours earlier.

The Bombers, minus a host of stars from their last gasp win over Collingwood the week before, fell to arch-rivals Carlton by 20 points, with Blues captain Stephen Kernahan booting seven goals. The win kept Carlton’s slim finals hopes alive, but the satisfaction of victory was quickly extinguished when news filtered through of Hawthorn’s stunning win over the Magpies at Waverley Park.

Jason Dunstall kicked 11 goals as Hawthorn romped to an 83 point win, virtually assuring the Hawks of a ninth-straight finals appearance. North Melbourne’s defeat of Footscray left the Kangaroos, Blues and Bulldogs all two wins and a hefty chunk of percentage behind the fifth-placed Hawks, essentially setting the participants for the 1990 AFL finals.

Nearly 36,000 fans piled into Subiaco for the blockbuster clash between two of the form teams of the competition. West Coast had won their previous five matches, while the Demons had rediscovered their early-season form to claim four wins on the trot.

The Eagles made two changes when teams were announced, with full-forward Peter Sumich returning after three weeks out with a hamstring injury. Phil Narkle was the other inclusion, with Peter Wilson sidelined with a broken jaw and Don Pyke dropped after just one game in the seniors.

Melbourne also made two changes, with John Howat and Brent Heaver both dropped and Garry Lyon and Steven Febey coming into the line-up. The Eagles were then forced into a third change when forward Craig McGrath withdrew ahead of the bounce, allowing Chris Waterman to make his first appearance of the season.

Waterman had endured a frustrating season on the sidelines after fracturing his ankle in a pre-season match, but had worked his way back into contention for AFL selection after strong form with Subiaco.

Demons coach John Northey had made the trip to Perth the week before to watch West Coast tackle the Tigers and his side followed the lead set by Richmond by approaching the game with physical intent.

Melbourne’s ferocity at the ball – and the man – saw them jump the home side with full-forward Darren Bennett finishing off the midfield ascendancy.

Jim Stynes took immediate control in the ruck against Dean Irving as Melbourne repeatedly sent the ball forward in the early exchanges. The Demons wasted their early chances, starting the match with three behinds, but Bennett soon gave them reward on the scoreboard.

Bennett booted the first four goals of the game, forcing Mick Malthouse to frantically shift around his under-siege defence. With Sumich back in the Eagles goal square, Peter Melesso started at full-back, but he lasted barely ten minutes before Michael Brennan replaced him on the last line.

Melesso was swapped to centre half back on Earl Spalding, Guy McKenna went to Garry Lyon and Steve Malaxos was sent to the back pocket.

Trailing 4.5 to nil, the Eagles worked themselves into the game late in the term, with Peter Sumich booting their only goal for the term.

Melbourne then started the second term as they did the first, with Bennett adding a fifth goal and Ricky Jackson crumbing from the top of the goal square to stretch the Demons lead out to six goals. Andrew Obst was dominant out of the middle of the ground off the back of Jim Stynes’ work in the ruck, while Steven Stretch and Graeme Yeats gave the Demons plenty of drive on the expanses of Subiaco.

But a late hit on Rod Grinter by Chris Mainwaring seemed to spark the home side into action.

The Eagles booted four goals heading into time on to reduce the margin down to 11 points. Troy Ugle came off the bench, as he has done on many occasions through the year, to have a hand in several chances and Dean Irving switched from the ruck to centre half forward where he took several strong marks and kicked the first of the goals to start the Eagles run.

Against the momentum of the game, Melbourne added two late majors. Andrew Obst set up Earl Spalding to run into an open goal, before Ricky Jackson finished off a chain of handballs from the next centre bounce to give the Demons an important break of 21 points at the main break.

The third term would prove to be one of the most exhilarating and controversial quarters of the year.

After being well held during the first half by McKenna, Garry Lyon was switched to the half back line, with Tony Campbell sent forward. Campbell kicked the opening goal of the quarter, but Karl Langdon responded after Jim Stynes failed to adequately clear the Demons defence.

Campbell then went to defence in a direct swap with full-back Danny Hughes who was struggling to contain Peter Sumich, despite the Eagles’ full-forward failing to maximise his chances on goal. The change had immediate effect with Hughes marking strongly in front of goal and converting.

Goals to Yeats and Stephen Tingay followed with Melbourne’s lead reaching 40 points.

The Eagles kept pressing with Waterman goalling twice, but for all of West Coast’s effort, the Demons were able to find a response. Seven goals to five in favour of Melbourne had them head to the final break with a 32 point advantage with the two teams as tensions between the clubs flared.

In the final seconds of the quarter, Jim Stynes’ swinging attempt to kick the ball of the ground only managed to connect with Dwayne Lamb’s arm, forcing the midfielder off with a suspected broken forearm. Chris Lewis was able to goal from the resultant free kick and at the next centre bounce, the Eagles players made their thoughts known when Stynes was collected at the ruck tap.

The animosity continued beyond the three quarter time siren between the players as a secondary melee broke out, while Demons coach John Northey and Eagles trainer Ian Monck also clashed as the pair were making their way to the respective huddles.

Dwayne Lamb finished with a broken arm after a stray kick from Jim Stynes

Any chance of a West Coast fightback in the final quarter was snuffed out early when Andrew Obst and Stephen Tingay kicked the opening two majors to all but end the contest. The midfield pair finished with 19 and 17 disposals, respectively, to be two of the best for Melbourne.

Jim Stynes was the architect, overwhelming both Irving and Phil Scott in the ruck and providing the Demons midfield with first use out of the stoppages. Simon Eishold was the leading ball winner for the Demons playing through the middle and across half forward with 26 possessions, while Brian Wilson was the next best with 24.

David Hart was initially assigned to Wilson, but couldn’t curb his work out of the middle, with Tony Begovich given the task after half time. Bennett finished with six goals for the afternoon, but his four-goal burst to start the match would provide the buffer Melbourne held for much of the afternoon.

Steve Malaxos was the leading possession winner in the game with 32, while midfielders Dean Kemp and Chris Lewis each collected 26. Lewis also booted three goals, as did Chris Waterman and Peter Sumich, who had a mixed afternoon.

Sumich almost summed up the Eagles’ afternoon in the final term when in the space of a minute, the full-forward fluffed two set shots. The first failed to make the distance from gettable range, while his second attempt only managed to go as far as the man on the mark.

The Eagles spearhead finished with 3.5 in his return match, but it could have been a double-digit haul if he made the most of all of his chances.

The fallout from the match continued in the days after.

Emerging Eagles utility Peter Melesso copped a five week suspension after being reported on trial-by-video for ‘assaulting Earl Spalding with his boot’ shortly before half time.

Footage showed Melesso stepping on Spalding as the centre half forward was on the ground, with Melesso arguing the contact was accidental. However the tribunal found Melesso guilty, leading chief executive Brian Cook to call the ‘whole AFL tribunal and video system frustrating’.

To further incense the Eagles, no action was taken on Stynes despite his swinging foot potentially costing Dwayne Lamb the rest of the season with a broken arm. Both club and player considered legal action over the incident, but ultimately chose not to, settling on a request to the AFL to re-define the law around kicking in danger.

Monck and Northey would both receive written warnings from the AFL over their stoush at three quarter time.

With the opportunity lost to cement the double chance, the Eagles now had to secure their place in the top three by getting wins on the road in the final two weeks against Brisbane and Geelong.

1990 Rewind: Sumich Injury Mars Bulldogs Win

~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

Mainwaring & Malaxos Lead Midfield Battle

West Coast continued their winning ways in Perth, but it came at a cost with full-forward Peter Sumich suffering a concerning hamstring injury.

The Eagles recorded their 14th straight win at home, jumping out to a five goal lead at the first change before holding the Bulldogs at bay for the rest of the evening to run out 43 point winners.

Peter Sumich was the key difference in the first half, booting six of the Eagles’ seven goals for the half, but his night quickly soured when he was helped off by trainers early in the third term. While Sumich remained upbeat after the match that the injury wasn’t too serious, coach Mick Malthouse was more downcast.

“Peter (Sumich) says he’ll be right for next week, but that would mean a miracle cure,” Malthouse said.

“Injuries like that are generally two to four weeks, so we’ll have to get by without our major goal-scoring avenue.”

The Eagles made two changes to the side to tackle Footscray with Brad Gwilliam and Dean Turner coming into the line-up. Turner replaced Dean Kemp, who had originally been named as a replacement for Brett Heady but was forced to withdraw ahead of the opening bounce. Stevan Jackson was the other omission, serving a one week ban for striking Russell Jeffrey.

Footscray arrived in Perth on a three game winning streak, having broken into the top five the week before after their win over Sydney. The Bulldogs made just the one change with captain Doug Hawkins returning to the side, replacing Mark Williams.

After conceding nine goals in the opening quarter against the Saints a week earlier, it was a vastly different start for West Coast.

The Eagles held the Bulldogs goalless in the opening term, kicking five goals with the breeze to take an early advantage. Peter Sumich kicked the first four goals in the match, proving a handful for Footscray defender Adrian Campbell with Peter Wilson swooping on a loose ball to add a fifth late in the term.

Footscray got on the board with two majors early in the second term, but Sumich added his fifth and sixth goals for the game to keep West Coast four goals to the good at half-time. Bulldogs coach Terry Wheeler was forced to shuffle his defence in a bid to stop Sumich, but in the end it was Sumich’s left hamstring that halted the full-forward’s influence.

Not that Wheeler didn’t have other matters on his mind.

Malthouse was winning the tactical battle between the two coaches as West Coast smashed the Bulldogs through the midfield.

David Hart and Dwayne Lamb were both assigned negative roles restricting the influence of Tony McGuinness and Tony Liberatore. Stephen Malaxos was matched against former Hawthorn teammate Terry Wallace in the centre and he claimed the honours with Wallace dragged during the third term, remaining on the bench until the final siren.  

Malaxos finished the game as one of the Eagles’ best with 35 disposals and a goal, but he was bettered for best afield honours by wingman Chris Mainwaring.

Mainwaring managed a personal best 45 disposals (20 kicks and 25 handpasses), falling just three possessions short of Malaxox’ club record 48 touches against the Saints in the final round of 1987.

The blonde Eagle provided the link between the Eagles defence and forward half, as West Coast regularly hurt the Bulldogs on the rebound. Without Sumich through the second half, the Eagles went small, with the goals shared amongst the midfield and half forwards.

Peter Sumich is helped off by trainers after damaging a hamstring

As well as Malaxos and Mainwaring, Chris Lewis (23 diposals) and Craig Turley (22) were both proficient through the middle and Guy McKenna provided the rebound with 20 touches. David Hart was able to get the better of McGuinness with 19 disposals and two second half goals.

Despite the attention of Dwayne Lamb, Tony Liberatore still managed to lead the Bulldogs’ ball winners with 29 touches. Brian Royal was arguably Footscray’s best with 23 touches and a goal, while Glenn Coleman had the better of Dean Irving around the ground to collect 27 disposals and eight marks.

Up forward, Chris Grant was providing a strong focal point for the Bulldogs. The 17 year old was too nimble for Michael Brennan but he wasted his chances on goal finishing with an inaccurate 2.5. Grant’s tally was symbolic of the Bulldogs night, with Terry Wheeler remaining positive about his sides’ finals hopes post-match.

“We blew a chance to consolidate our place in the top five, but I couldn’t question the endeavour of the players or the way they fought the game out.”

“With a bit more goal-shooting luck, we could have been five points behind at quarter-time, not five goals and that would have made a big difference.”

The defeat saw Footscray fall back out of the five as the rest of Round 16 played out. Hawthorn moved back into fifth position with a percentage boosting win over Richmond, courtesy of an 11 goal performance from Dermott Brereton.

Brereton himself outscored the Tigers by four points as Hawthorn controlled the contest from the outset to run out 91 point winners. The Hawks had yet to show their premiership winning form of 1989 on a consistent basis, but were doing enough to keep themselves in the finals hunt.

Carlton also moved past the Bulldogs when they beat an inaccurate St Kilda at Princes Park. The Saints had five more scoring shots, but still went down by 15 points to the frustration of coach Ken Sheldon. Nicky Winmar (4.5) and Ricky Nixon (0.4) were the main culprits on the scoreboard, with the defeat all but ending St Kilda’s finals hopes for 1990.

1989 Grand Finalists Geelong also appeared done for 1990 when they slumped to a 27 point loss to Fitzroy. The Cats led by five points at half-time, but ten goals to five after the major break saw the Lions home at Waverley Park. Paul Roos (six goals) and Richard Osborne (four) were the difference between the two sides.

The race for the final spot in the top five was effectively down to four clubs, with the Hawks, Blues and Bulldogs all sitting on nine wins and the Kangaroos still in the hunt, one win back, after they came from four goals down at quarter time to defeat the Brisbane Bears by 36 points.

At the head of the ladder, the Magpies moved one game clear after Melbourne produced a stunning resurgence against the Bombers. The Demons were staring down the barrel of a fourth straight defeat early in the final quarter at Windy Hill when Greg Anderson’s goal from the boundary stretched the Bombers lead out to 34 points.

Melbourne then produced a stunning flurry, booting seven goals in 17 minutes to secure a narrow win, and right their ailing season. Collingwood moved to the top of the ladder with a 24 point win over the Swans in an entertaining clash. The two sides combined for 40 goals in the match with Sydney defying their second-last position to take it right up to the Magpies.

Collingwood led by five goals at three quarter time, but on three occasions in the final term the Swans closed within five points. However the Magpies were able to settle and bank the four points.

The Eagles sat comfortably third on the ladder following the win over Footscray and with games to come against Carlton, Sydney and Richmond, hopes of a double-chance finish were well within their sights.

1990 Rewind: Job Done, Eagles Eye Pies

~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

Eagles One Point Away From Double Chance

Fitzroy made West Coast work, but the Eagles’ class rose to the top as they pulled away to a 37 point win at Subiaco Oval.

The Eagles led by just eight points at half-time against the lowly Lions, but a seven goal third quarter separated the two sides, consolidating the Eagles’ position inside the top five.

Peter Sumich booted six goals and Brett Heady four, while Dean Kemp put in the finest performance of his 12-game career to collect 35 disposals.

Sumich’s haul saw him move to the top of the Coleman medal, overtaking both Tony Lockett and Darren Bennett to lead the competition with 56. Lockett had been the pacesetter at the start of the season, booting 52 goals in the first eight games. But the Saints spearhead had been sidelined with a medial ligament injury since, allowing the likes of Sumich, Bennett and Kangaroos full forward John Longmire to make ground on the goalkickers list.  

With the state-of-origin clash between Western Australia and Victoria taking place at the W.A.C.A. in the lead up to the Fitzroy clash, the Eagles had had a 16 day break following their win over the Hawks.

However, the gap between the two games hadn’t equalled a relaxing period for many of the players.

12 Eagles were selected for WA, with a further three – John Worsfold, Dwayne Lamb and Phil Scott – pulling out ahead of the match due to niggles lingering from the Hawthorn game.

Steve Malaxos captained the WA side, with key Eagles players Chris Mainwaring, David Hart, Chris Lewis and Peter Sumich partaking. Brett Heady was selected for his state debut after a stellar start to his first AFL season, while squad member Tony Evans (who had yet to join his Eagles teammates since being drafted the previous year) and under-19 sensation Glen Jakovich were also picked.

WA were favourites to beat the Victorian team, who had already been embarrassed by New South Wales and Tasmania in earlier state-of-origin matches, but the ‘Big V’ were able to restore some pride with a 37 point win.

Simon Madden claimed the Simpson medal with a dominant performance in the ruck, while Gary Ablett (six goals) and Paul Salmon (four) ably filled the positions that were normally reserved for injured pair Tony Lockett and Jason Dunstall.

Eagles coach Mick Malthouse admitted the state-of-origin hadn’t been ideal for his club.

“It is a fact that interstate football affects the Eagles more than any other team in the competition.”

“While we are the only AFL side in WA, we will always provide a large proportion of players for the match,” Malthouse continued. “The disruption makes it extremely hard to prepare the side for a game during what is a vital part of the season.”

Malthouse suggested playing interstate matches as a pre-season carnival would be of greater benefit.

Following the interstate game, the Eagles had several players facing fitness tests to play the Lions.

Chris Mainwaring was the greatest concern, lining up for WA despite having scans on his knee. Guy McKenna (groin), Dwayne Lamb (achilles), Michael Brennan (groin), Karl Langdon (wrist) and Peter Wilson (groin) all needed to get through training, while Brett Heady suffered bruised ribs after being collected heavily front on by Simon Madden, while playing for WA.

When the teams were released, all were selected to play, with the suspended Craig McGrath the only change to the side that defeated the Hawks. Stevan Jackson – who had been dropped for the previous game after a poor run of form – was given the chance to reclaim his spot in the senior side as McGrath’s replacement at centre half forward.

Mainwaring would ultimately pull out ahead of the opening bounce, with Todd Breman coming into the side.

The Lions flew to Perth having found their best form ahead of the split round. Wins over Hawthorn and Sydney came either side of a competitive effort against the Kangaroos. And unlike West Coast, Fitzroy had enjoyed the benefit of a fully rested squad, with only ruckman John Ironmonger taking part in the mid-week interstate clash.

The Lions made two changes to the side that defeated the Swans in their last start by 45 points. Paul Broderick and Mark Trewella were both dropped in favour of Darren Kappler and David Strooper.

Interestingly, the Lions chose not to bring back full forward Richard Osborne, who had impressed in three consecutive reserves games in his comeback from a serious knee injury suffered the year before.

Regular defender Murray Rance started on the bench for the Eagles, with Phil Scott preferred at centre half back against Fitzroy superstar Paul Roos. At the other end, Alastair Lynch lined up at full back on Peter Sumich, while Kappler returned to the middle, opposed to Dean Kemp.

Despite half the side coming off just a five day break, there were no signs of sluggishness from the Eagles when they burst out of the blocks with the opening four goals, to establish a 21 point lead. Fitzroy soon closed down the contest and with Roos getting the better of Scott at half-forward, the Lions were able to work their way back into the game.

Fitzroy had almost 40 more disposals in the second quarter as they started to control the centre line. Matthew Dundas had 10 disposals on his own for the term up forward for the Lions, while Scott Clayton and Andrew Johnston had seven each as Fitzroy got on top through the middle.

Dale Kickett was relatively well held in the match, but his extraordinary checkside kick from the 50m arc helped Fitzroy bridge the Eagles lead back to eight points at the major break.

Twice during the third term Fitzroy drew within two points, but Troy Ugle sparked the Eagles up forward when he was switched from the back pocket. Ugle booted a goal and had a hand in four others as West Coast piled on seven for the quarter – five of which came in just nine minutes.

Leading by 39 points at the final change, the Eagles continued on with their momentum in the final term, but Wally Matera came off the bench to add three late goals and reduce the final margin.

The final quarter effort from Matera would prove costly for his former side. The Eagles were set to replace the Demons in third spot, but lost crucial percentage as Matera got off the chain, leaving West Coast sitting in fourth spot – just 0.07% behind the Demons.

In fact, just one more point would have been enough to elevate West Coast into the double chance positions.

Fitzroy coach Rod Austin conceded the Eagles’ burst in the third quarter was costly for his side. “We had done well to fight back, but we missed some opportunities – and that has been the story of the year as far as we’re concerned.”

Eagles coach Mick Malthouse was understandably pleased with the win, but quickly moved the focus post-match to the upcoming clash against the Magpies at Victoria Park.

“You haven’t played football until you’ve played at Victoria Park.”

Malthouse admitted that there was plenty to work on ahead of the Eagles match against the second-placed Magpies, but believed a lack of continuity had affected his sides’ preparations.

“… the past three weeks have been indifferent, in as much as we rarely trained together.” Happy to get the win and take the four points, Malthouse said his side ‘used the ball correctly after half-time.’

As well as Kemp’s 35 possession game through the middle, he was ably supported by captain Stephen Malaxos who tallied 32 touches. Chris Lewis finished with 27 possessions and Brett Heady recovered enough to pick up 25 rotating through the middle and half forward.

Paul Roos did all he could to keep the Lions’ in the contest with 19 disposals, 11 marks and 3.3 from centre half forward, but there were too few who could sustain the pressure on West Coast for the full four quarters. Michael Gale and Tony Woods each picked up 23 touches to lead the ball winners for the visitors, while former Eagle Wally Matera finished with four goals and Roos and Matthew Dundas three each.

The Eagles sat two games clear in fourth spot with nine wins after Hawthorn fell to the Bulldogs by 17 points at Waverley Park. The Hawks were replaced by the Saints in the top five, after David Grant booted five goals to engineer a 33 point win over a flat Melbourne.

Four teams sat behind the Eagles on seven wins as the race to qualify for the 1990 finals appeared to be down to one final spot. St Kilda, Hawthorn, Carlton and Footscray were all in the battle, with the Blues’ win over Geelong appearing to end the Cats finals’ hopes.

The Cats again paid dearly for woeful goal kicking, booting 13.26 in a 19 point loss. Ken Hinkley was the biggest culprit for Geelong finishing with 2.7, while Robert Scott managed just four behinds. The result followed similar matches earlier in the year when the Cats dropped points to Richmond and Sydney because of inaccurate kicking.

At the top, Essendon and Collingwood stayed a game ahead of the competition with routine wins over Brisbane and Richmond.

Malthouse believed his side was well placed heading into the second half of the season, but knew the Eagles’ greatest test would come the following week against one of the premiership favourites.

“We’ve had a good win under our belts and a good week of training in front of us before we go to Victoria Park.”

1990 Rewind: Eagles’ ‘Character’ Win

~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

Malthouse Lauds His Players Fighting Finish

Mick Malthouse declared in the lead up that it would be the Eagles’ greatest test of character.

The Eagles, coming off two disappointing losses to North Melbourne and Essendon and with their hold of a top five place under threat from the swarm of sides clambering to break their way into finals contention, needing to win against the twice-defending premiers.

West Coast’s poor record in Victoria had once again become the conversation as many questioned the Eagles legitimacy in the premiership race. Poor form had also seen a number of changes in recent weeks, unsettling the Eagles line-up.

To further frustrate Malthouse, incessant rain during the week prevented the Eagles from running their main training session on the WACA, which was sitting under a deluge of water. Players and staff arrived at the ground only to find a square tarp across the middle of the cricket wicket, forcing a mad dash back to Subiaco Oval.

However, by the time players had battled peak hour traffic to reach the other side of the city, the session was lost.

“We feel like lepers,” Malthouse said.

“That’s the sort of treatment we expect when we go to Melbourne and what Melbourne teams should cop when they come here.”

“It’s the same argument we had with them last time… Our whole preparation has been messed up.”

Like West Coast, Hawthorn had hit a mid-season stumble. After winning four of their first five games, including an emphatic 115 point demolition of Geelong in the opening round grand final rematch, injuries and suspensions had the Hawks similarly fighting for their top five spot.

Spearhead Jason Dunstall was sidelined with a fractured skull and Dermott Brereton was serving a four game suspension for striking Garry Lyon. The Hawks would also lose captain Michael Tuck ahead of the opening bounce after he failed a fitness test. Veteran Peter Schwab would take his place in the midfield, joining ruckman Stephen Lawrence who was named as an inclusion when teams were first announced.

The Eagles made just one change to the team that lost to Essendon, with Stevan Jackson dumped in favour of rookie midfielder Dean Kemp. Craig McGrath was shifted to centre half-forward, joining Sumich and Langdon in a three-pronged attack.

Hawthorn opted to change with routine, flying into Perth on the morning of the game.

At half-time, they may as well have still been on the plane.

The Eagles got the fast start on the visitors, kicking seven first quarter goals – four of which were booted by full forward Peter Sumich – to open up a 31 point lead at the first change.

The runners of West Coast were running rings around a sluggish Hawthorn, with rookie Brett Heady leading the way through the middle. Heady, along with Chris Lewis and Steve Malaxos were winning plenty of ball around the contest, with Chris Mainwaring giving the drive along the wing.

Steve Malaxos led from the front with 23 disposals in the middle

The Hawks closed the game up in the second quarter, managing to hold the Eagles to just one goal, kicked via Chris Lewis, but were unable to hit the scoreboard themselves going goalless. Making matters worse for the Hawks, Gary Buckenara and Peter Curran had both left the ground with knee injuries, meaning they were without a bench for the remainder of the game.

When Malaxos goaled early in the third quarter, the Eagles lead was out to 40 and the game looked done.

But Hawthorn then raised a gear, storming back into the contest with eight of the next nine goals. When John Platten – who was well held by David Hart all night – kicked truly just before three-quarter time, the Hawks had taken the lead, unthinkable just half an hour earlier.

Greg Dear was the architect of the Hawks’ comeback as he gained the upper hand in his intriguing battle with Eagles ruckman Dean Irving. Dear finished the match with 41 hit-outs, to go with 22 disposals and eight marks. In particular during the third term, Dear provided first use to the Hawk’s midfield brigade, with Dean Anderson, Anthony Condon and Peter Schwab all enjoying plenty of the ball.

The Eagles grabbed back the lead before the final change, before Platten booted his second goal early in the final term to put the Hawks back in front.

That would be the last salvo from the Hawks, as West Coast met the visitors’ challenge to boot five of the last six goals in the game. The Eagles rediscovered their run against a tiring Hawthorn outfit, with defenders Guy McKenna and Michael Brennan both running down the ground to kick goals.

Sumich added a fifth in the final term to take his season tally to the half-century mark and third on the goal kickers list behind Tony Lockett (52) and Darren Bennett (51).

Heady finished with 28 disposals and seven marks, while Chris Lewis and ruckman Dean Irving were the next best with 26 disposals. Guy McKenna had 21 coming out of defence, while Michael Brennan shut out Alex McDonald who came onto the ground as Buckenara’s replacement.

Malthouse was understandably pleased with the result.

“You’ve got to be happy when you beat Hawthorn.”

“Some might say that you throw (Dermott) Brereton and (Jason) Dunstall into the Hawthorn team and we lose that game, but who knows.”

Malthouse admitted that the Hawks got the better of his players through the middle stages, as they clamped the Eagles run.

But Allan Jeans said his side didn’t do enough to contain West Coast’s midfield, with their influence at the start and end of the match decisive in the defeat.

“Their running players got on top and created opportunities for their forwards and then we played catch-up footy for most of the night.”

Anthony Condon was the leading ball winner on the night with 30 disposals, and was well supported by Dean Anderson (29) and Peter Schwab (28), but not enough players were able to contribute across the night.

Without the key pillars of Brereton and Dunstall, the Hawks couldn’t gain an ascendancy forward of centre, bar the third quarter. Paul Dear kicked three goals and Stephen Lawrence and John Platten each chimed in with two.

Malthouse lauded his players for their continued fight in the last quarter.

“We sent 20 players down the race and they sent 20 and it was a terrifically courageous last quarter. We had some of our guys running up and down on the spot and they still came from behind to win.”

The result saw the two sides switch positions on the ladder, with West Coast moving up to fourth and the Hawks dropping to fifth. The Eagles remained one game behind Essendon, Melbourne and Collingwood, who all recorded victories.

The Bombers defeated the Kangaroos, while Melbourne and Collingwood beat finals aspirants Footscray and Geelong. They remained a game behind the Hawks outside the top five, along with St Kilda and Carlton.

The Blues easily defeated Brisbane at Princes Park to lift themselves into seventh, but it was the Saints who were kicking themselves the most after the suffered a shock defeat to the Tigers. St Kilda booted eight goals in the opening term, but were slowly reeled in the Tigers over the next three quarters, with a five goal final term giving Richmond a 20 point win. The defeat cost the Saints a chance to move back into the top five.

The string of results across the round meant the Eagles sat two games inside the top five and maintained their hopes of securing a double chance. But while there were plenty of positives to take from the win, the sour point of the evening was a two game suspension handed out to Craig McGrath, who was cited for striking Ray Jencke in the final minutes of the match.

With the upcoming state-of-origin clash between WA and Victoria at the WACA the following Tuesday week, those Eagles not selected had a fortnight to recover before the Eagles’ next game against Fitzroy in the second weekend of the split Round 13.