1990 Rewind: Big Fish Sinks Eagles

June 10, 2020June 10, 2020 ~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

Eagles Drop To The Edge of Finals as Forwards Misfire

It was a tale of the full forwards as West Coast dropped a second consecutive game to leave their finals aspirations sitting on the brink at the halfway mark of the season.

Windy Hill lived up to its name as the Eagles struggled to handle the swirling breeze that encased the ground with a forward line function that was virtually non-existent.

The Eagles were unable to contain Essendon full-forward Paul Salmon, who booted six goals from 20 disposals and 14 marks alternating between the forward line and in the ruck, while Peter Sumich was held goalless by Anthony Daniher.

In fact, not only did Sumich fail to register a goal, the Eagles spearhead failed to register a possession, despite spending all bar three minutes on the ground.

Stevan Jackson was another who struggled up forward, managing just a kick and a handpass in the opening half, before spending the entire second half on the bench.

The 39 point defeat left the Eagles precariously placed in fifth position, as a host of teams pressed their claims for a spot in the top five.

The disappointment of the previous weeks effort against North Melbourne lingered through the week, as coach Michael Malthouse took his team to task.

A brutal two and a half hour training session on the Monday was followed by a tackling session led by rugby league coach Russ Devonshire with Malthouse keen on igniting aggression towards the opposition.

The Eagles were then savage at match committee, dropping seven players for the clash with the Bombers. Peter Matera, Dean Turner, Geoff Miles, John Annear, Scott Watters, Dean Kemp and Don Pyke all lost their spots, with the Eagles inclusion centred around height to battle the plethora of talls at Essendon.

Craig McGrath was selected for his club debut after being picked up in the pre-season draft, following six seasons with Fitzroy. Dean Irving was also recalled for his first game since round 3, to partner Phil Scott in the ruck against Essendon pair Simon Madden and Paul Salmon. Geelong and North Melbourne had both exposed the Eagles in the ruck in recent weeks, with Phil Scott going it alone.

Peter Wilson, Dwayne Lamb and John Worsfold all returned after missing the loss to the Kangaroos through injury, while Craig Turley and David Hart were also welcomed back to the side. Troy Ugle held his place up forward after being a late replacement for Worsfold the week before.

Essendon were forced to make four changes, due to a raft of players left unavailable after their 90 point win over Sydney. Derek Kickett, Billy Duckworth and Ian McMillan were all out injured, while Andrew Manning copped a two week suspension.

Into the Bombers line up came defender Chris Daniher and midfielders Adrian Burns, Tony Antrobus and Ed Consadine. Kevin Walsh pressed his claims to return from a knee injury, but failed to recover in time.

In tricky conditions, the first half was a tightly fought affair.

Paul Salmon made his first imprint on the game with three goals in the opening quarter as Essendon opened up a 13 point quarter time lead. The two teams then managed just one goal between them as the game developed into a fierce lockdown.

Trailing by 18 points at the main break, the Eagles started the third quarter brightly, but ill-discipline undid much of the early good work in the term as Essendon were handed a string of easy goals.

The Eagles gave away three 50m penalties in the quarter, all of which directly resulted in goals for the home side. Greg Anderson kicked a goal from the first penalty, with Salmon then the recipient of the next two as he booted another three goals in the term to take his match haul to six.

Two goals late in the term to Troy Ugle kept the Eagles within 21 points at the final change, but a five goal to two last quarter sealed the win for the Bombers and consolidated their position at the top of the ladder.

**Chris Lewis was the exception up forward for the misfiring Eagles, booting three goals**

After the match, Mick Malthouse was blunt about his non-firing forward line.

“When we get the ball as often as we did and don’t score as often as our opposition – that is our breakdown.”

The Eagles matched the Bombers in total disposals and managed nine more forward 50 entries (64-55), yet registered four less scoring shots.

“At no stage did our forward line click”, Malthouse continued.

Malthouse was also forthright in his assessment of the umpires, questioning the legitimacy of the 50 metre penalties awarded against his side in the crucial third quarter.

“One was soft,” an exasperated Malthouse declared, “and I could almost argue about (the other) two of them.”

“I get sick and tired of trying to justify how good or bad the umpires are. It’s time (national director) Bill Deller… have a good look at the situation.”

Chris Lewis was the best forward for the Eagles on the day, finishing with three goals from 20 disposals across half forward. Lewis also proved he had paid attention during the week, laying eight tackles in the match.

Chris Mainwaring had 26 disposals on the wing and Stephen Malaxos was again industrious in the centre with 24 disposals and a goal. Dwayne Lamb and David Hart both had successful returns with 21 and 20 possessions, respectively.

Craig McGrath also impressed in his first game as an Eagle, collecting 21 disposals and six marks, showcasing his wares at both ends of the ground.

However, the Eagles had no answer for Salmon, who was arguably the difference between the two sides. Dean Irving was tasked with the role of tagging Salmon around the ground, but appeared out of his depth and the Eagles backline were again exposed for height against the taller forwards in the competition.

Simon Madden booted two goals while resting forward, with Salmon’s haul of six coming a week after John Longmire booted eight goals for the Kangaroos.

Greg Anderson finished as the leading possession winner for the Bombers with 26, while Terry Daniher was the next best with 24 touches and 11 marks. Tim Watson also booted a brace of goals from 22 disposals and Mark Thompson finished with 23 and eight marks through the middle.

The result moved Essendon a game clear of the Eagles, and they were joined by the Magpies and Demons. Collingwood recorded a routine win over the bottom-placed Bears at Carrara, while Melbourne survived an incredible Carlton comeback to fall over the line.

The Demons streaked away to a 56 point lead midway through the third term, off the back of a five goal performance from debutant Brent Heaver. However, the Blues stepped into gear to kick the final five goals of the term and reduce the Demons advantage to 21 at the final change. Carlton continued to surge with Stephen Kernahan leading the charge in the final term, but a poor return of 3.6 left them six points short.

Hawthorn also moved ahead of the Eagles when they had little trouble defeating the Swans, despite being without Jason Dunstall. John Platten booted five to be the surprise leading goal scorer for the Hawks, who returned to the top five in place of St Kilda.

The Saints lost their place in the five with a narrow eight point defeat to the Cats. In a high-tempo clash, Geelong worked their way to a 25 point advantage at the final change, before second-year Saint Robert Harvey dragged his side back into the contest. Harvey booted four goals in the final quarter to bring St Kilda within touching distance of the lead, but Stewart Loewe and Tim Pekin missed simple chances late in the game, which ultimately proved costly.

The result meant that St Kilda and Geelong both sat one game behind West Coast, as did Footscray who did what they had to in a 14 point win over Richmond. The Eagles’ hopes of finals now rested on a crunch home game against the 4^th-placed Hawks the following week.

While the 39 point defeat wasn’t the desired outcome, the Eagles could find some solace in this performance compared to the previous season. In the corresponding fixture of 1989, West Coast conjured up just one goal for the afternoon in a 160 point shellacking – a 20 goal improvement on their last visit to Windy Hill!

1990 Rewind: Eagles Storm Home

May 30, 2020May 30, 2020 ~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

Captain’s Call Pays Off

West Coast rode the wind – and the tide – with a seven goal final quarter that sealed a 19 point win in a rollercoaster game of momentum played in driving rain.

In one of the games of the season, the lead changed hands 12 times, and were level three times during the final quarter, before the Eagles were able to come out on top.

Recalled midfielder John Annear stood up in a desperate final quarter as he, Steve Malaxos and Chris Lewis inspired the Eagles to the gutsy win.

Annear was the only change for the Eagles, replacing Tony Begovich who had made his debut the week before against the Bears.

The Cats made three changes coming into the match, as they looked to arrest an embarrassing slide that had seen them drop games against cellar dwellers Richmond and Sydney.

David Cameron, Tim Darcy and Bruce Lindner were all dropped, with Ray Sterrett, Neville Bruns and Dwayne Russell all brought into the line-up. Geelong coach Malcolm Blight was conscious of the wide expanses of Subiaco Oval bringing in players renowned for speed to match the equally pacy Eagles.

The Cats though were still without match winner Gary Ablett, who had been unavailable since having surgery to repair knee cartilage heading into Round 6. Ablett had carried the injury since the Cats night series match against the Kangaroos, although that hadn’t stopped his proficiency in front of goal, booting 24 goals in his first four games of the season before being sidelined.

The first decisive moment of the match, came before the match, when Eagles captain Steve Malaxos won the toss but chose to kick into the gale that was sweeping towards the Subiaco end. West Coast then bounced out of the gates, kicking the opening three goals into the wind and holding onto a six point advantage at the first break.

However, the Cats were just as effective into the wind, restricting the Eagles to just one major although West Coast also had themselves to blame with six behinds for the term. The Eagles led by just two points at the main break, and were down a man after Peter Wilson limped off with a hamstring injury.

The second half then became a battle for momentum.

The Cats were far more effective with their second use of the wind, booting five goals for the term to open up an eight-point lead with a quarter to play. Adrian Fletcher had been kept quiet by Malaxos through the first half, but broke free in the third term with 12 disposals as he, Paul Couch (eight disposals) and Neville Bruns (six) took control through the middle.

Geelong ruckman Darren Flanigan provided the service for his midfielders at the ruck, overwhelming Phil Scott, and later Stevan Jackson. Flanigan finished with 39 hit-outs for the game as Geelong held an ascendancy at the stoppages.

However, the Eagles did enough to hang in the contest, mostly through the work of Chris Mainwaring on the wing and Karl Langdon up forward. Mainwaring was one of the Eagles’ best in the first half with 16 disposals and continued his fine work after half-time picking up nine disposals for the term.

Langdon had started the game on the bench alongside John Annear, but he burst into the game after half-time with three of the Eagles four goals for the quarter.

And as the rain dissipated before the start of the final term, Malaxos’ decision at the coin toss became vindicated. Chris Lewis and Phil Narkle provided the class in the final term, along with several desperate acts from Annear to get West Coast over the line. Annear also bobbed up for a vital goal at the start of the quarter and proved an astute inclusion given the conditions.

**A bloodied John Annear was instrumental in the final quarter surge**

After the game, a beaming Malthouse declared his side had answered another one of the Melbourne media criticisms. “We played tough footy in ordinary conditions and that’s what footy is all about – tough and relentless.”

“I would like to keep the dry tracks in Perth but we won’t be disappointed going to Melbourne in the rain.”

Malthouse, though, admitted his side were lucky with the gamble at the toss. “It was raining and we were fortunate to come home with the wind and without the rain.”

Mainwaring finished with 30 disposals for the match, while Chris Lewis and Stephen Malaxos were the next best with 23. Peter Sumich continued his strong form for the season, booting 5.4, stepping up with multiple goals in the final term as West Coast surged.

Geelong coach Malcolm Blight praised his side’s effort and intensity but shared disappointment with some of the ball use. “That touch of class at the end is not working for us.”

Barry Stoneham provided a focal target up forward and Garry Hocking was one of the best for the Cats, but they had too few contributors across the day.

“We’ve been having a dip over the past three weeks and we have lost three games by small amounts,” Blight said.

The third-straight defeat left the Cats with a tough task ahead through the second half of the season, sitting two games and hefty percentage behind the fifth-placed Magpies. However, Blight refused to concede the finals’ hopes of last year’s Grand Finalists were over.

“It’s mission impossible when you’re two games out with one game to go.”

The win saw the Eagles draw level with the Melbourne at the top of the ladder, although they remained in second spot behind the Demons on percentage. Melbourne suffered their second loss of the season when they were easily brushed aside by a Hawthorn side who were keen to atone for their humiliating loss to Carlton a week earlier.

The Hawks moved up to fourth, in place of St Kilda, who dropped out of the top five when they fell to Essendon at Windy Hill. In the battle of 3rd and 4th, the Lockett-less Saints pushed the Bombers all the way, but came up 11 points short.

Collingwood forced their way back into the top five for the first time in a month, when they thrashed North Melbourne by 80 points at Victoria Park. Gavin Brown and Peter Daicos each booted seven goals as the Magpies slammed on 11 final quarter goals to secure an important percentage-boosting win.

The Magpies moved a game clear of the Saints, who were joined by Carlton and Footscray on the edge of the finals’ spots, after they recorded easy victories over Fitzroy and Brisbane.

While the Eagles could feel satisfied with a hard-earned four points and equal-top spot on the ladder, they were less than thrilled with the AFL judiciary, who returned a no-result over their investigations involving Annear and Hocking. The pair clashed twice in a fiery last quarter, with Annear requiring two sets of stitches to repair cuts on his face.

But with Channel 7 unable to supply footage of the incidents from the match, the AFL determined there was insufficient evidence to move forward. Eagles general manager Brian Cook conceded the club wouldn’t lodge an official complaint over the incidents.

1990 Rewind: Eagles Bounce Back Against Bears

May 22, 2020May 22, 2020 ~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

Eagles Get Four Points But Miss Percentage Booster

West Coast returned to winning ways when they comfortably accounted for the Brisbane Bears at Subiaco Oval. In a performance that warranted a triple-digit winning margin, poor kicking on goal meant the Eagles had to settle for a 59 point victory.

Peter Sumich booted four goals, as did Geoff Miles who was thrown forward in the second half. With such a complete performance, many Eagles stood out, but the performance that would have most delighted the West Coast match committee was that of Phil Narkle, who returned for his first senior match in over two and a half years.

Narkle – a member of the Eagles inaugural squad of 1987 – was delisted at the end of 1988 after injuries restricted the gifted wingman to just nine games in two seasons. Returning to the WAFL, Narkle managed some games with Swan Districts late in the 1989 season, with the Eagles throwing a lifeline ahead of the 1990 season, with their final selection at the pre-season draft.

Narkle’s last appearance for the Eagles had been the 130 shellacking against Sydney in Round 16 of the 1987 season.

Narkle shone in his first game back, picking up 22 disposals and booting 2.3 playing mostly from the forward pocket. Malthouse, in particular, was delighted by Narkle’s showing.

“I was tickled pink with Phil’s game, especially as he was a bundle of nerves beforehand,” a ‘rapt’ Malthouse said after the game.

“His pace and genuine crumbing ability gave us something that we lacked.”

Narkle was one of four inclusions for the Eagles, who swung the axe after their poor display against the Demons the previous week.

Chris Mainwaring earned an instant reprieve after being dropped to East Fremantle the week before, responding as one of the best players for West Coast. Scott Watters and Tony Begovich were the others brought in, with Craig Turley, Andrew Lockyer and Todd Breman dropped. Dean Laidley was finished for season 1990 having undergone a knee reconstruction during the week.

Begovich debuted for the Eagles after being selected at the 1989 National Draft, but his selection capped off a rampant rise. Begovich initially rejected the Eagles offer to join the club, choosing instead to remain with WAFL club Claremont, alongside fellow draftee Peter Mann.

However, a change of heart in the new year saw Begovich join his new Eagle teammates and a strong start to the WAFL season garnered his first senior AFL game. While he spent most of his first match on the bench, Begovich still managed to have an impact booting his first goal.

The need for Begovich was limited as West Coast controlled the contest from the get go.

The Eagles registered 13 scoring shots in the first term and the game could have been done at the first change if not for an inaccurate return of 4.9.

Chris Mainwaring slotted back on a wing and gave plenty of drive, as did rookie Peter Matera who produced a more rounded effort in his 3rd AFL game. Fellow rookie Brett Heady provided class through the midfield and at half forward, while Peter Wilson was industrious around the ground.

The Bears had arrived in Perth off the back of their second win of the season, by eight points over Sydney, with forward Cameron O’Brien the difference in the win with seven goals. However, he was completely blanketed up forward by Michael Brennan. Murray Rance was similarly effective on Bears captain Roger Merrett.

Guy McKenna provided the drive from the backline and with Karl Langdon and Stevan Jackson up forward, along with Sumich and later Geoff Miles, there was too much class across the ground for the Bears to contain.

The Eagles added another four goals in the second term, and put the foot down after half time with six majors to take their lead out to 60 points with a quarter to play. However 2.7 in the final quarter cost the Eagles a chance at a significant percentage boost.

Remarkably, the Eagles booted 8.13 in each half, to finish with one of their most inaccurate displays in the clubs history, a final score of 16.26, from 42 scoring shots.

Mainwaring, McKenna and Wilson all tallied 26 disposals to be the leading ball winners for the Eagles, with rookies Dean Kemp (22 disposals) and Brett Heady (21 disposals, two goals) also impressive. The only concern for West Coast was full forward Peter Sumich limping off midway through the third term.

Bears coach Norm Dare admitted his side were ‘just not tough enough’ in the contest with the result undoing much of the good work they had showed the week before.

Ironically for the Bears, their best players were also Eagles. Mark Zanotti, John Gastev and Alex Ishchenko had all been a part of the Eagles’ inaugural squad, but had worked their way east to the Bears in subsequent seasons.

Zanotti was the leading possession getter for the Bears with 25 from defence, while Gastev offered an avenue to goal with 18 touches and two goals. Ishchenko was the Bears’ best on the day, completely monstering Phil Scott in the ruck and getting the better of his former teammate around the ground.

Ishchenko finished with 18 disposals and 10 marks, while also having 25 hit-outs in the ruck, compared to just nine for Scott.

While happy with the win, Malthouse bemoaned the missed opportunities on goal. “We worked hard to set up goals rather than kick them.”

And despite the win lifting the Eagles back up to second spot on the ladder, a game clear of the chasing pack, Malthouse acknowledged the win would mean nothing if they lost to the Cats the following week.

“We have to defeat Geelong next week,” Malthouse declared. “That will put us three games up on them.”

“In the wash-up, after 22 rounds they (Geelong) will be vying as we will be, for a place in the five.”

It was déjà vu for the Cats when inaccurate kicking cost them what should have been a straight forward win against a side at the bottom of the ladder. A week on from their shock defeat to Richmond at Kardinia Park, the Cats booted 13.20 in their nine point loss to the Swans at the SCG, who had started the round in equal bottom.

The consecutive defeats had robbed the 1989 Grand Finalists the chance to sit comfortably inside the top five, instead languishing in eighth position, a game and percentage out of the top five. Carlton pushed past the Cats into seventh when they won their third straight match, thrashing the Hawks.

The Blues led from the outset and slammed their advantage home in the final term with an eight goal quarter securing a 67 point win. The Hawks would be the big losers of the round, dropping from 2nd on the ladder to 5th.

Essendon and St Kilda each climbed a spot with narrow wins over Footscray and North Melbourne, respectively, while the Magpies remained stayed in touch with the top five with a ten goal final term turning a 17 point three-quarter time deficit into a 45 point win over Fitzroy. The Demons remained the pacesetters at the top of the ladder with an easy win over the Tigers.

Sumich Eight Eclipses Swans

May 2, 2020 ~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

Eagles Climbing After Third Straight Win

Eight goals from Peter Sumich helped West Coast to a commanding 61 point win over Sydney at Subiaco Oval. The Eagles recorded their third straight win to take their season record to 4-1, rising to third on the ladder.

The Eagles were sandwiched between the Hawks and Magpies, with all three teams on four wins, while the Demons remained the competition benchmark with their fifth win from five games after demolishing the Bears.

Sumich’s haul of eight came in two bursts during the game, mirroring the performance of West Coast through the match.

The Swans arrived in Perth without a win since round 1 and had lost key midfielder Greg Williams to a broken thumb the week before in their defeat to St Kilda. Sydney kept pace with the Eagles early in the game, before three goals to Sumich in time-on helped the Eagles build a 26 point lead at the first change.

West Coast remained in control of the game during the second term as they extended their lead to 43, before the Swans mounted a comeback after half-time. Sydney ruckman Michael Parsons took hold of the ruck combining with rover Gerard Healy to drive the visitors back within touching distance.

Healy had been well contained by Dwayne Lamb in the first half, but racked up 11 disposals in the third quarter as Sydney took over in the centre square. Healy had strong support from fellow midfielders Steven Wright (nine disposals) and Barry Mitchell (eight disposals) as the Swans slammed on five goals for the quarter to reduce the deficit to just 23 points at the final change.

Sumich had failed to add to his goal tally since quarter time, but another four goal burst in six minutes to start the final quarter snuffed out Sydney’s comeback effort. Three of those goals were set up by second-gamer Brett Heady, who was one of the Eagles’ best with 21 disposals and two goals.

Sumich kicked a fifth late goal for the quarter late in the term, finishing with a career-best eight for the match, equalling his effort against the Bulldogs in round five the year before.

Troy Ugle provided the perfect foil for Sumich up forward with three goals from 22 disposals and eight marks, while Peter Wilson (22 disposals) and Guy McKenna (21) were major ball winners for the Eagles. McKenna’s performance was even more striking considering the defender was forced off the ground during the third term with food poisoning.

**Troy Ugle was a focal point up forward with three goals**

McKenna’s departure from the game coincided with the Sydney’s strongest period of the game, as they converted centre square ascendancy into scores. But, unlike West Coast, the Swans didn’t have a reliable target in their forward arc, with Murray Rance a major roadblock in defence. Rance finished with 21 disposals and seven marks and had the better of a number of Swans opponents who were tried in the key forward position.

Malthouse again praised his defensive unit, admitting that it wasn’t his side’s best performance. John Worsfold stepped into McKenna’s role after he departed the field, while Dean Laidley was strong off the other half back flank.

For Sydney, Gerard Healy finished with 29 touches in his battle against Dwayne Lamb, while Barry Mitchell racked up 28 touches, although was less effective through the centre with Steve Malaxos for company. Neil Cordy tried hard in defence and Stevie Wright had 22 disposals to go with his three goals.

With the final quarter still fresh in his mind, Sydney coach Col Kinnear expressed disappointment in his sides’ ‘very soft’ finish. “As a realist, you can’t think of finals’, Kinnear said.

Mick Malthouse though was happy to take the four points from the underwhelming performance, as West Coast consolidated their position in the top five.

Eagles Continue Blues Misery

April 25, 2020April 25, 2020 ~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

Eagles Coast To Thumping Win

West Coast made it three wins from four games when they easily defeated the Blues in their round four clash, in front of a record attendance at the WACA.

A crowd of 28,568 were on hand to witness the Eagles 50 point win, bettering the ground’s previous highest attendance at the Australia v Pakistan one-day international the previous summer.

The Eagles extended their lead at every change in the routine win, which was highlighted by the impressive debut of midfielder Brett Heady.

Heady had starred for Subiaco four days earlier in the Lions’ 50 point win over Perth, and despite the short turnaround, gathered 18 disposals and booted two goals in a notable performance first-up effort with West Coast.

The inclusion of Heady was one of three for the Eagles after their thumping win over Footscray. David O’Connell was selected for his first match of the season and Michael Brennan returned from a groin injury picked up in the round two defeat to St Kilda. Paul Peos was ruled out with a knee injury, while Brad Gwilliam and Dean Irving were both dropped.

After losing their first two games, the Blues arrived in Perth off the back of a 14 point win over the Saints. However the win came at a cost with both Mark Naley and Simon Minton-Connell injured and subsequently ruled out against the Eagles. Chris Bond was also dropped, with David Glascott, Ian Herman and Andrew Phillips all included.

With Minton-Connell sidelined and Stephen Kernahan used through the ruck with Justin Madden unavailable for selection, the Blues lacked any forward presence.

Richard Dennis kicked the opening goal after receiving a 50m penalty, but the Eagles had control of the play from early in the game. Only the strong defensive efforts of Stephen Silvagni and David Rhys-Jones prevented West Coast from hitting the front, but when Peter Sumich and Karl Langdon goaled right before quarter time, the Eagles had taken a lead they would not relinquish.

Three goals to one in the second term extended the Eagles’ lead to 20 points at the main break, but the lead could have been so much more if not for inaccurate kicking. Dean Laidley and Guy McKenna created plenty of drive off half back, the pair combining for 20 disposals in the second quarter alone.

Laidley had picked up 19 disposals by half time, while debutant Heady tallied eight touches in the second quarter, as did Stephen Malaxos and Dwayne Lamb. As West Coast flexed their superiority in the game, things got worse for the Blues when they lost Silvagni to injured ribs after a heavy collision, denying the Blues another of their key talls.

With his side needing a spark, Alex Jesaulenko swung Rhys-Jones to full forward and got an immediate response as Rhys-Jones booted three goals in six minutes to bring the Blues back within touching distance.

However, West Coast settled with the final five goals of the quarter to take their lead out to 38 points, before a six-goal final term ensured a comfortable win.

Sumich led the Eagles goal kicking with four majors, while Peter Wilson and Craig Turley each booted three.

Laidley finished with 30 disposals after his barnstorming first half and Stephen Malaxos was industrious through the middle with 29 touches. As well as hitting the scoreboard, Wilson and Turley were both productive with the ball, collecting 25 and 22 dipsosals respectively.

Dwayne Lamb shut down Craig Bradley on the wing, while the Eagles defence, led by Laidley, Guy McKenna and Murray Rance were again steadfast. After four rounds, the Eagles had conceded the least amount of points – 310 – in the league; 118 of which came in the loss to St Kilda.

“Our backline is functioning very well”, a delighted Malthouse declared after the game. “It’s early days, but its slowly and surely coming about.”

The win lifted the Eagles back into the top five at the expense of North Melbourne, who dropped out after a five goal defeat to Geelong. West Coast sat in fifth, percentage behind the Saints, Hawks and Bombers, with Melbourne still undefeated when they overturned a half time deficit to defeat Fitzroy.

With winnable games to come against lowly Sydney and Richmond, the Eagles were primed to consolidate their position in the finals placings, despite starting to build a concerning injury list.

Chris Mainwaring had missed a fortnight with a back fracture, while Chris Lewis and Chris Waterman both remained sidelined from injuries picked up in the pre-season. John Annear and Don Pyke were both injured the previous week playing for their respective WAFL sides after falling out of the Eagles line-up following the Saints defeat, while Tony Begovich and Andrew MacNish were also injured the previous week in the WAFL.

Geoff Miles hadn’t made an appearance at any level as he battled a hamstring injury and Paul Peos was expected to miss the majority of the season with a knee complaint.

1990 Rewind: Mick’s Happy Returns

April 17, 2020 ~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

Malthouse Gets Last Laugh on Former Club

West Coast players declared they would play for their coach, and did so accordingly when they recorded a comfortable 63 point win over the Bulldogs in their round three clash at the Western Oval.

Six months after parting ways with the Bulldogs as they sat on the verge of extinction, Malthouse returned to his former home of six years to claim the four points.

Malthouse’s desertion had not been forgotten by his former players or fans in a hostile build up to the match. Several Bulldogs players were critical of Malthouse after a radio interview Malthouse gave during the week, believing Malthouse had been derogatory towards them and the club.

Fans also voiced their displeasure towards their old coach before the match and at each interval, although Malthouse later played down the hostile reception post-match.

“There were so may well-wishers before the game. It made me humble I suppose that there are people here – even though they’re Footscray people – who felt like that.”

“The disappointing thing is that I’ve listened to a couple of interviews by former players who tended to put the boots in, when I believe I gave them the opportunity to play League footy”, Malthouse continued.

“You have to look at human beings for what they are. Some put dirt on you. Some are great friends.”

And while the new Eagles coach suggested that he was greatly unaffected by the comments coming out of his old club leading up to the game, he did little to hide his emotion at the final siren, embracing many of the Eagle players on the ground.

The West Coast players, for their part, declared they would ‘play for their coach’ in response to the negative comments arising out of Footscray and did so with a defensive masterclass, restricting the home side to a measly 1.8 at half time.

The Eagles themselves booted nine goals for the half to take a commanding 50 point lead into the main break, and were never in danger of giving up the four points in the second half.

The win was a strong response to the humbling 58 point loss to the Saints the week before.

The Eagles made five changes, three of which were forced through injury. Wingman Chris Mainwaring was found to have a small fracture in his back, which was set to sideline him for two weeks, defender Michael Brennan had a groin strain and Don Pyke couldn’t be considered due to soreness.

John Annear and Andrew Lockyer were the casualties as Malthouse injected more speed into the side. Steve Malaxos was named for his first game as captain, while Stevan Jackson was named across half forward. Craig Turley, Scott Watters and David Hart were the other inclusions, all of who were named for their first games of 1990.

The Bulldogs named an unchanged line up to the one that easily accounted for the Swans in Sydney. However they were dealt a couple of blows before the opening bounce with John Georgiades (hamstring) and Steven Kolyniuk (ankle) both forced out. Danny Del Re came in for his debut game, with Matt Hannebery the other inclusion.

West Coast also made a late change with Chris Lewis replaced by Todd Breman. Lewis had been a surprise inclusion during the week after failing to last a quarter against the Saints with an ankle injury and was duly ruled out.

The Bulldogs started the brighter of the two sides, but the Eagles soon gained the ascendancy in the match.

The Eagles squad had been heavily criticised about their lack of commitment to the contest against the Saints, and put on an improved attack on the ball. Peter Wilson and Steve Malaxos led the way as West Coast bullocked their way to a three goal to one lead at the first change, before the Eagle runners took hold of the game in the second quarter.

Troy Ugle, Dwayne Lamb, Craig Turley and David Hart were all prolific as West Coast booted six unanswered goals, to all but end the contest. The Eagles were particularly devastating coming out of defence with handball, the quick transition catching the Footscray defence out of position.

The three-pronged attack of Peter Sumich, Karl Langdon and Stevan Jackson benefited most from the Eagles impressive ball movement. Sumich could have had a day out, finishing with a wasteful 3.4 from 14 kicks and 11 marks, while Langdon also booted three goals. Jackson had a presence further up the ground with nine disposals, five marks and a goal.

The performance of Langdon would have been pleasing for Malthouse, after several players had rotated through centre half forward in the first fortnight of the season. Dean Irving, Andrew Lockyer and Phil Scott had all been tried in the opening two weeks, but Langdon made the most of the opportunity against the Bulldogs, getting the better of three opponents.

**Karl Langdon impressed at half-forward getting the better of Stuart Wigney, Greg Eppelstun and Peter Foster**

In contrast, the Bulldogs forward line failed to function against the miserly Eagles defence. Murray Rance kept Barry Standfield to just seven disposals and without viable targets, the Bulldogs were forced to take long range shots on goal, with little success.

Bulldogs coach Terry Wheeler threw his side around to start the second half, pushing Chris Grant to full forward, Stuart Wigney from defence to the forward line and Leon Cameron to the wing. The moves paid some dividends with Grant (twice) and Cameron kicking majors in the third term as both sides booted four goals.

The Eagles then finished with a five goal to two last quarter to record their highest ever score in Victoria. Along with Sumich and Langdon, Craig Turley and David Hart also finished with three goals, while Troy Ugle chimed in with two.

Peter Wilson led the disposals for West Coast with 30, with Dean Laidley (24) and Turley (23) the next best.

The Bulldogs were best served by Terry Wallace who finished with 32 disposals and a goal and Stephen Wallis who tallied 25 touches. Grant booted another goal in the final quarter to finish with a match haul of three, while Wigney also gave the Bulldogs life in the forward line, managing six shots on goal in the second half but only booting 1.5 opposed to Brad Gwilliam.

Bulldogs coach Terry Wheeler was scathing in his review of the game, saying that the senior Bulldogs players weren’t up for the match against West Coast. At three-quarter time, Wheeler took many of his younger charges aside and spoke with them away from the rest of the squad for several minutes.

“They’re earmarked to be the future of the Footscray Football Club and if what I was seeing from some of our senior players is the attitude they have toward football at the moment, I certainly don’t want our younger players to… take that attitude.”

“… those senior players today, for one reason or another, didn’t show us that they can play”, Wheeler bemoaned.

The win lifted the Eagles back to the edge of the top five, as one of six teams that had two wins from their opening three games. Only the Demons remained undefeated at the close of Round 3, following their 27 point win over Essendon.

As well as booting their highest ever score in Victoria, the Eagles 63 point win was also their largest, bettering the 37 point win over Footscray at the same ground the year before. The victory also made it three in a row for the Eagles at the Western Oval, defying their overall poor record away from home.

The only sour note for the Eagles was the knee injury to Paul Peos during the second quarter, which was set to sideline the wingman for much of the season.

The Injury compounded a poor week for Peos who had been fined by the club during the week for breaking team rules, and then being on the end of some ‘friendly advice’ by the ground announcer when he was involved in a skirmish with Leon Cameron on the members wing before the opening bounce.

1990 Rewind: Malthouse Begins

April 1, 2020April 1, 2020 ~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

Off-Season of Change Brings Winning Start

The 1990 season promised a new beginning.

The AFL was officially born with league headquarters re-branding from the VFL to recognise that the competition was now national, with clubs located in Victoria, New South Wales, Queensland and Western Australia.

The West Coast Eagles had also undergone significant changes since a disappointing 1989 campaign.

John Todd was replaced as coach after two seasons, with Victorian Michael Malthouse taking over the reins following six seasons at Footscray. The Bulldogs had only made the finals once during Malthouse’s tenure as coach, falling agonisingly short of a Grand Final appearance in 1985 in Malthouse’s second year.

The Bulldogs had remained competitive since, hovering just outside the final five, before crashing to second-last in Malthouse’s final year in charge, as the club battled football extinction. The Bulldogs would exist in their own right for season 1990 – saved from merging with Fitzroy – but Malthouse sought a new challenge across the Nullabor.

The transition between Todd and Malthouse hadn’t been a smooth one; news of Malthouse’s appointment had been leaked before Todd was formally told he would not be offered a new contract, with the Eagles hierarchy scrambling together a press conference on the afternoon of October 3, 1989 to present Malthouse as the clubs third coach.

Malthouse would not be the only key change for the Eagles heading into 1990.

Brian Cook was appointed CEO, after two years with the WAFC, and Trevor Nisbett was appointed football manager. On-field, Stephen Malaxos was named captain with John Worsfold vice-captain and the club was able to establish Subiaco Oval as its permanent training base, having operated out of a number of different locations across their first three seasons.

Leading up to the clubs opening game against Collingwood, the signs were positive the Eagles could return to finals action.

The Eagles lost narrowly to Essendon in their Fosters cup opening game, but were given a reprieve in the competition after Brisbane failed to travel down for the pre-season competition. West Coast played the Bears’ opponent in North Melbourne, and narrowly lost again. The Eagles lost both games by three points, with poor kicking for goal to blame in both defeats.

West Coast then hosted the previous seasons Grand Finalists in practice matches to round out the pre-season. Both were resounding victories. The Eagles thrashed the Cats by 89 points and then followed up that performance with a 12 goal win over the Hawks.

West Coast named a fresh squad to tackle the Magpies, who were one of the premiership favourites heading into the season. Collingwood had made the finals the previous two seasons under Leigh Matthews, but had been bundled straight out in both years. With a number of key recruits over the off-season, many believed the Magpies were ready to take the next step.

The Eagles named four players for their AFL debut. Peter Matera – the Eagles first selection at the 1989 draft – Dean Kemp, Dean Irving and Brad Gwilliam were all selected for their first matches, while Peter Wilson was also picked for his first game with the club, having switched across from Richmond.

John Worsfold was left to lead the club, after new captain Steve Malaxos was forced to miss the game with a broken foot. Malaxos had suffered the injury, stepping on a picket at his home, missing the start of the season.

The Magpies named new recruits Tony Francis and Scott Russell, who had both joined the club from the SANFL, but prized addition Paul Hawke and defender Michael Christian were both unavailable due to hamstring injuries.

The two sides had met in the final round of the 1989 season, with Collingwood easy 49 point winners.

But in a clear sign of how much the Eagles had progressed in one summer, West Coast extended their lead in every quarter to run away with a 46 point win.

In a bruising encounter that had plenty of moments of spite between the two sides, it was an all-in brawl midway through the third quarter that set the course of the final outcome. Collingwood first-gamer Tony Francis lashed out at Eagles defender Murray Rance as the two tumbled over the boundary line, sparking an altercation that involved most players from both sides.

Play was held up for several minutes as the umpires tried to separate the players and when the two teams did get back to playing football, it was the Eagles who settled quicker. The Eagles booted the next three goals to stretch their lead out to 34 points, and while Collingwood responded with the last two goals in the term, a five goal to two last quarter sealed an impressive win for the home side.

Peter Sumich starred up forward with six goals, but it was the improved defensive attitude that pleased new coach Mick Malthouse most. Collingwood could manage just eight goals for the afternoon, with Michael Brennan shutting out full forward Brian Taylor and Murray Rance the better of Craig Starcevich.

**Sumich led the way up forward with six goals**

Dean Laidley had the better of Jamie Turner, while John Annear found a new role in defence, marked with the task of minding Gavin Brown.

The Magpies struggled throughout the day with the man-on-man structure that Malthouse implemented, as well as the intense pressure around the ball.

“They (the players) didn’t talk about how much they’d won by or who kicked the goals. The first thing they said when they came in was the tackling was terrific”, an excited Malthouse proclaimed after the match.

“They acknowledged each other and it’s important that they think that’s one criterion of success, either at Subiaco Oval or Melbourne.”

Troy Ugle was stationed in the back pocket for the Eagles and provided plenty of dash through the first half, before being forced off the ground when he was caught under the pack of the melee, injuring an arm in the process. However, he returned to the field in the forward line for the final quarter, booting a goal and setting up two others in a best-afield display.

First-gamer Dean Irving combined well with Phil Scott in the ruck with the duo proving too strong for Collingwood pair Damien Monkhorst and James Manson at the stoppages. The Eagles midfield benefitted from this advantage with Paul Peos the leading ball-winner with 25 disposals and Chris Mainwaring next-best with 22.

Dean Kemp had 20 touches on the wing to get the better of Graeme Wright and Dwayne Lamb restricted Peter Daicos to just six kicks and a goal.

After having his colours lowered by Paul Tuddenham in the first quarter, acting captain John Worsfold was released into the middle, where he finished with 19 disposals and gave plenty of drive along with Karl Langdon, who collected 21 touches and booted two goals roaming between half forward and the centre.

For Collingwood, only captain Tony Shaw (24 disposals), newcomer Scott Russell (22) and Darren Millane (21) showed they were capable of matching the fierceness that West Coast brought to the contest.

It only got worse for the Magpies, with Francis later suspended for six games for kicking Rance. In his tribunal hearing, Francis remarked that he had been provoked when he felt Rance brush his groin area, and while he admitted responding with a kicking action, believed that he had missed Rance. The Eagles defender supported the claim by Francis that he didn’t make any contact, but that didn’t stop tribunal chairman Neil Busse rubbing the Collingwood midfielder out until round 8.

The Eagles themselves weren’t immune from the tribunal, with runner Rob Wiley charged for his involvement in the melee. Wiley was sanctioned and fined $1000.

While the result proved an awakening to the rest of the competition, Malthouse remained calm, saying there was plenty for his side to work on.

“If you come away from round one with a win, and plenty of work to do, that’s good.”

West Coast Demolish Cats For 1994 Flag

September 26, 2019September 26, 2019 ~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

Two Out Of Three Ain’t Bad For Eagles

West Coast reinstated themselves as the kings of the competition when they crushed Geelong by 80 points to win the 1994 Grand Final.

Two years after an historic first flag, the Eagles steamrolled the Cats to their second premiership, erasing the disappointment of a failed 1993 season.

Dean Kemp claimed the Norm Smith medal for best afield and Tony Evans repeated his 1992 haul of three goals as West Coast booted their highest score in over two years.

Traditionally recognised as a defence-oriented side, the Eagles racked up 43 shots on goal in the Grand Final, a week after they posted 37 scoring shots against Melbourne. Ten Eagles in total hit the scoreboard as West Coast recorded the fourth largest winning margin in Grand Final history.

For the Cats, the defeat was their third loss in the season decider in six seasons, having gone down to the Eagles by 28 points in 1992 and the Hawks by six in 1989.

A shattered Malcolm Blight could offer no explanation after the match, saying there was ultimately nothing his side could do. “I could say a million things about what we might have done or could have done. But at the end of the day they were 80 points better than us, which is pretty hard to cop really.”

Eagles coach Mick Malthouse admitted he sympathised with the Cats, but was equally ecstatic with his side’s performance.

“I just love seeing the day for the club and all the players… I get a bigger kick out of seeing the players enjoy themselves.”

West Coast made just one change from the preliminary final, with Ashley McIntosh coming back into the team after missing with a knee injury. Mitchell White was the player to make way, after coming into the side as McIntosh’s replacement, but remained an outside chance on the morning of the game as West Coast debated whether to remove one of their ruckman.

However, the pair of David Hynes and Ryan Turnbull was retained to tackle John Barnes who was openly struggling with a lower leg injury. Geelong remained unchanged from their last-gasp six point win over North Melbourne, with Grant Tanner ruled out earlier in the week in his bid to recover from an ankle injury.

McIntosh started in defence on Bill Brownless, with Michael Brennan tasked with minding Gary Ablett. The Cats tried to throw the Eagles defence early, starting Ablett on the wing but he quickly moved to the goal square after failing to have an impact.

In a reverse to the 1992 meeting, it was West Coast who had the fast start, booting the first three goals in the game. Tony Evans, Chris Lewis and Shane Bond all kicked majors as the Eagles jumped to a 20 point lead.

West Coast had had all of the play out of the middle of the ground but the momentum of the game soon changed when Geelong piled on four goals in eight minutes. Tim McGrath and Michael Mansfield provided the dash off half back for the Cats with Paul Couch opening the Cats account.

Three more goals followed in quick time to give Geelong a seven point lead, before Brett Heady settled the Eagles just before quarter time to reduce the Cats lead to one point at the first change.

It would prove to be the only period of ascendency Geelong would have in the game.

West Coast resumed control at the start of the second term and only poor kicking on goal prevented the Eagles from having the game won by half time. Peter Wilson kicked consecutive goals to start the quarter as West Coast camped the ball in their forward half.

The Eagles created confusion at the Geelong kick-ins when they changed tack from their usual one-on-one set up to a zone defence. The usually precise Mansfield and Ken Hinkley were undecided with their re-entries preventing clean getaways from their back half, which had been a trademark through their finals campaign.

Twice in the second quarter West Coast picked off their kick-ins. Tony Evans intercepted a Ken Hinkley pass to mark and goal, before then having an intercepting hand that rebounded to Peter Sumich allowing the Eagles full forward to send the ball back over his opponent in Stephen O’Reilly.

The Eagles continued their dominance of general play but, remarkably, when Bill Brownless booted his third goal midway through the third term, the Cats were still within touching distance trailing by just 18 points.

However, three majors to Dean Kemp, Brett Heady and Peter Sumich extended their lead to six goals by three-quarter time and Geelong’s slimmer of Hope was all but gone.

The last quarter was a celebration for West Coast, as they slammed on eight goals to one to demoralise the opposition and the majority of the pro-Geelong crowd.

Symbolic of the day for West Coast and for their Norm Smith medallist Dean Kemp, their 17th goal came about purely by accident. Kemp’s kick inside 50 was intended for Chris Lewis who was crunched out of marking the ball by Tim McGrath, only for the ball to carry on its path and bounce harmlessly through for another goal.

Kemp was sublime for the Eagles on a day when they had a healthy number of contributors. The Eagles centreman had 23 disposals and booted two goals to outpoint Geelong captain Mark Bairstow, who had a dirty day. It also meant that Bairstow finished with the inglorious honour of once again playing on the Norm Smith medal, after lining up on Peter Matera’s wing in his five goal performance of 1992.

**Dean Kemp was best afield for West Coast**

Don Pyke collected 26 possessions through the middle and just had the edge over Geelong’s Paul Couch. One of Geelong’s prime movers was relegated into a defensive role as he tried to curb the influence of the Eagles centreline.

The Eagles defence was as impregnable as ever, led by Glen Jakovich (20 possessions) and Guy McKenna (23) across half back. Jakovich played his own game standing in the way of Geelong’s forward entries and proving too strong for both Steven Handley and David Mensch. McKenna provided the run from the backline as he outclassed Adrian Hickmott.

Michael Brennan blanketed Gary Ablett, with the Geelong superstar managing just one goal from five disposals and David Hart had the better of Leigh Tudor in the back pocket. Geelong’s only winner in their forward half was Billy Brownless, who exorcised some of his demons from the 1992 Grand Final when he was humbled by Ashley McIntosh.

Brownless kicked four goals for the Cats – he was the only Geelong player to kick a goal after quarter time – and took one of the great Grand Final marks when he soared over McIntosh and managed to hold onto the ball from a second attempt.

Michael Mansfield was arguably the Cats best player with 21 disposals out of defence and having the better of Shane Bond, while Tim McGrath also did his best to withstand the avalanche. Garry Hocking finished with 20 possessions after being forced off during the first term with a heavy cork and returning to the ground in the second half with heavy padding around his upper leg.

But it was a day that belonged to West Coast.

15 members of the 1992 triumph were now dual premiership players, while there was redemption for David Hynes and David Hart, who were the unlucky stories from two years earlier.

And even with two of the heroes from 1992, in Peter Sumich and Peter Matera, having subdued outings, there were plenty of others who stepped up. Sumich and Matera combined for 11 goals in the clubs first flag as West Coast had just four goal kickers for the day. This time around, nearly half of the team kicked goals, as the likes of Chris Lewis, Brett Heady and Jason Ball provided strong targets up forward.

Chris Waterman came onto the ground early in the second term after Chris Mainwaring was forced off with a corked hip and put in one of his finest performances with 18 disposals and two final quarter goals (to go with four behinds). Mainwaring himself was able to return to the field and pick up 18 disposals.

Mick Malthouse even broke with his own tradition in heading down to the bench with three minutes remaining. Malthouse had been reluctant to leave the box two years earlier, despite the urging of his coaching team, but with the game well in his side’s keeping, the Eagles coach revelled in the celebrations boundary side.

Malthouse admitted that he knew his side were home during the third quarter.

“We expected at some stage Geelong to give us a big quarter like they had over the last three or four weeks, so we were ready for it. We stuck to our basics, not to allow them to get that one quarter of football in.”

“At half-time I thought if we maintained our pressure, and we could hold them, we could do the job,” Malthouse said.

“So I guess three quarters of the way through the third quarter I thought we had them.”

Since taking over as senior coach at the end of 1989, Malthouse had steered the Eagles to no lower than fourth in five seasons, which now included two premierships from three Grand Final appearances.

The Eagles had massacred the Cats in one of the most emphatic premierships of the modern era and with that staked their claim as the pre-eminent club of the AFL.

1994 Rewind: Eagles Remain On Course Despite Magpie Scare

September 12, 2019 ~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

The Eagles survived a Gavin Brown inspired comeback to defeat the Magpies by two points and progress to a home preliminary final.

West Coast weren’t expected to be troubled by the eighth placed Magpies, but scraped over the line when Mick McGuane dropped a chest mark within scoring distance, seconds before the final siren. Trailing by 24 points at the final break, Collingwood surged home with the aid of the Fremantle Doctor, narrowly falling short of a famous finals victory.

The Magpies only booted six goals in the first three quarters, but doubled their tally in the final term with Brown booting three, on his way to a match haul of five.

In a match filled with controversy, umpires twice failed to hear the siren at the ground, allowing play to continue well beyond the signal for the end of the quarter. On both occasions West Coast posted scores with a Don Pyke behind at the end of the second quarter allowed to stand despite the siren blaring for nearly 10 seconds before umpires heard it. Play was also allowed to continue beyond the three-quarter time siren, with Chris Lewis slotting a goal, only for umpires to then correctly annul the score ahead of the fourth quarter.

The errors around the siren almost proved catastrophic in the two point margin.

Despite arriving in Perth off consecutive losses to St Kilda and North Melbourne in the final two rounds of the regular season, the Magpies were confident they could replicate their 37 point victory from when the two sides met earlier in the season.

Surprisingly, the hero of their Round 13 victory, Andrew Tranquilli, was not initially named in the Magpies line-up, with Gary Pert returning to the side after missing the final game with a groin strain. Pert passed a vigorous fitness test to take his place, while Tony Shaw was also included despite concerns over a hamstring strain.

Mark Fraser was included along with Pert, replacing Paul Sharkey and Brett James. However, Tranquilli made his way into the final 21 as one of two late inclusions, with Sharkey reinstated after being dropped. The duo came in on the morning of the game, replacing Tony Woods and Kent Butcher.

The Eagles made two changes to their side named on Thursday night, with Dean Kemp and John Worsfold returning in place of dropped duo Paul Symmons and Drew Banfield. Banfield could consider himself unlucky to lose his spot having played all 22 home and away games, with Mick Malthouse saying team balance was the reason behind his omission.

After releasing their squad, the Eagles were still on tenterhooks until the following afternoon, with five players fronting the tribunal for their roles in the spiteful clash against Footscray the previous weekend. West Coast were able to breathe a sigh of relief when Glen Jakovich, Peter Sumich, Chris Lewis, Tony Evans and Jason Ball were all cleared to play.

Gavin Brown won the toss but gave West Coast first use of the strong afternoon breeze that favoured the end where the WACA’s famous cricket scoreboard sat. The move initially worked with West Coast failing to capitalise early under the pressure of Collingwood’s physical intent.

Even before the opening bounce, the emergency umpire was required on the field to disperse players and Don Pyke sought treatment from the Eagles medical staff after a crunching hit. When the Eagles’ first goal did come, it was via a relayed free kick after Mick McGuane bowled over Chris Mainwaring.

McGuane was doing his best to distract Mainwaring, as one of a number of enterprising moves from Leigh Matthews to stifle the Eagles’ prime movers. Usually playing through the centre, McGuane started on a wing in a defensive role on Mainwaring, while the hard-running Fraser went to the other wing on Matera in an attacking move.

First year forward Trent Hotton was preferred to spearhead Sav Rocca at full-forward, with Jason McCartney lining up at centre half forward on Jakovich. McCartney’s role was purely as a decoy, dragging Jakovich into the deep pockets of the WACA. Nathan Buckley lined up on a half forward flank opposed to McKenna but became the pseudo centre half forward with McCartney pushing wide.

When Tony Francis was released into the Magpies forward 50 to goal on the run, the Magpies had drawn level with West Coast and Brown’s decision at the coin toss was looking a masterstroke. However, the Eagles were able to finish the term with a flurry of goals to take a 12 point lead into quarter time.

Shane Bond ran into an open goal, Peter Sumich kicked his second for the term and after Nathan Buckley launched a long bomb into the wind, Chris Lewis out-bodied Gavin Crosisca to mark and goal to close out the term.

The quarter time break brought further changes for the Magpies. Tony Shaw had lasted less than a minute before the hamstring went, with the former captain resigned to the bench for the rest of the afternoon. Shane Kerrison came onto the ground in his place and was given the task of minding Dean Kemp, while Jon Hassall was sent to Tony Evans, with the Eagles duo running riot in the opening quarter.

The Eagles maintained the status quo for the second term extending their lead by two despite defending against the wind. Jason Ball kicked the opening term after marking a Sumich set shot on the goal line, before Trent Hotton roved a marking contest to keep the Magpies in the game. Brett Heady got out the back to kick the Eagles second for the quarter but the Magpies were able to respond again through Gavin Brown with just 44 seconds remaining in the term.

The first missed siren of the afternoon came at the half-time break, with play allowed to continue deep in the Eagles forward line as the siren wailed in the background. No umpire on the ground heard the siren, with play only coming to a stop when Don Pyke scrounged home a behind. The score stood.

West Coast took complete control in the third term, but it took two magical moments from Peter Matera to get some separation from the Magpies. The Eagles were inaccurate early, kicking four straight behinds with Peter Wilson also sending a shot out on the full. Brett Heady finally found the major opening before Matera put his first stamp on the game.

The Eagles wingman had worked into the game after a slow start opposed to Mark Fraser, picking up nine disposals in the second quarter. After Chris Lewis missed yet another shot on goal, the Magpies clearance from the kick-in only went as far as Jason Ball on the wing. His quick handpass released Matera who sent a long shot on goal from inside the centre square which sailed post high on the wind and lifted the mood of an anxious home crowd.

Tony Francis got an immediate response after receiving a free kick at the next centre bounce and then a 50m penalty paid against Jakovich. Unable to get into the game in the first half, Jakovich was swung forward during the third term but he was forced back to the backline just minutes later when Ashley McIntosh went down with a hamstring injury.

Collingwood grimly hung on in defence for the rest of the term, with Damien Monkhorst providing extra support sitting in the Eagles forward 50. In the final minute, Matera provided his second highlight of the term.

Gathering a loose ball on the wing, Matera went on a jinking run, weaving his way past several Collingwood opponents before finishing from 40m on the run. Umpires again failed to hear the siren when it called for three quarter time, with Chris Lewis kicking truly from the pocket. Originally given a goal, the decision was overturned by the non-officiating umpire in the middle of the ground who had heard the siren ring before Lewis got boot to ball.

**Peter Matera was electric in the third term**

West Coast managed 3.7 for the quarter and for all of their dominance, the 24 point three quarter left Collingwood in the game, with the advantage of the Fremantle Doctor in the final term.

And the Magpies wasted no time to get themselves back into the game with three quick goals to start the final quarter. The Collingwood skipper had moved to the goal square, with McKenna as his new opponent, kick-starting his side with the opening goal. Tony Francis booted his third for the game after Mainwaring is captured in the Magpies forward line, with Brown then kicking his second for the term after a relayed free kick was paid against Peter Matera.

After being caught holding the ball in the middle of the ground by Mark Fraser, Matera – incensed by the umpires decision – flatted Tony Francis well after he disposed of the ball, injuring his back in the process. Brown reduced the margin to just seven points, while Matera hobbled off the ground, joining McIntosh in taking no further part in the game.

Chris Lewis provided a settler to take the Eagles lead back out to 13 points, but two errors in as many minutes from the normally unflappable McKenna had Collingwood within a point of the lead. Failing to get the ball over the boundary line on the half back line, McKenna gave up possession of the ball to Brown with a chain of handballs ending with Tranquilli who slotted home on the run from the pocket.

From the Magpies’ next forward entry, McKenna again had the ball and looking to rush through a behind, sent the ball out of bounds alongside the behind post. The defender was pinned for deliberate out of bounds and Brown was able to snap home his fifth goal of the match from the resultant free kick.

The Magpies had cut the Eagles lead to just one point with still eight minutes to play, but the Eagles defence held strong against the wind. David Hynes was standing tall in his battle with Damien Monkhorst and with the clock continuing to count down, released the Eagles with a 30m spike from a ball up on the wing.

Chris Lewis pounced on the loose ball across half forward and after an exchange with Peter Wilson, sent a scrubby ball towards the top of the goal square. Collingwood defender Craig Kelly couldn’t hold onto the mark, allowing Brett Heady to swoop and run into an open goal. With under two minutes remaining, the Eagles lead was eight points, but there was still plenty to play out.

Jason McCartney had the Magpies back within two after being set free through the middle of the ground and with only seconds on the clock, Collingwood had one final thrust forward.

Jon Hassall won a free kick on the wing and released Gary Pert with a handball, with the defenders long kick floating towards half-forward. Mick McGuane found himself best placed, but spilled the mark allowing West Coast to hold on.

After the match, Malthouse praised the spirit of his players in fighting the game to the end. “It was a great win for us. But we knew Collingwood were always going to tough it out. You don’t expect any different from Collingwood.”

Malthouse refused to accept that the distraction of the tribunal in the lead up to the game had had any impact, instead expressing disappointment over a number of ‘easy’ goals that kept Collingwood in the game.

Magpies coach Leigh Matthews was equally full of praise for his side, declaring that the brace of goals from Matera in the third term was the difference in the game. “I would go as far to say that is what beat us.”

“A couple of goals that come from just a pure, sensational one-off. A bloke grabs the ball from midfield and says ‘don’t worry about anyone else, I’m going to finish’, Matthews exclaimed.

“We got beaten by maybe just those two fantastic individual efforts by him at that point… I thought for the rest of it, we hung in there fairly well.”

The thrilling finish capped off an incredible weekend of results in the AFL’s first instalment of the top eight system. The Cats made it through their qualifying final against the Dogs courtesy of a Billy Brownless goal after the siren. Geelong got the blistering start with an eight goal opening quarter, but the Dogs clawed their way back into the game to trail by just two points at the final change.

In a see-sawing last term, Footscray appeared to be home when Simon Atkins put them in front with just 24 seconds remaining, but a Geelong clearance from the next centre bounce landed in the lap of Brownless. Brownless coolly finished to get the Cats over the line.

Earlier that day, North Melbourne and Hawthorn played the first ever final that required extra time, when the two sides were locked at 91 points apiece. The Kangaroos dominated the extra time period, kicking 3.5 to 0.0 in the additional playing time, with Wayne Carey guiding his team to victory.

The narrow defeat was exacerbated 24 hours later for the Hawks when seventh placed Melbourne upset the second placed Blues. After an even first half, the Demons exposed Carlton’s lack of pace to run away with a 27 point win and keep their finals hopes alive, when defeat would have ended their season.

That meant the sixth placed Hawks joined Collingwood on the scrapheap for 1994 and also saw North Melbourne join the Eagles with direct entry to the preliminary final.

Malthouse admitted the week off would be beneficial for the Eagles, with injury concerns over Ashley McIntosh and Peter Matera. West Coast would wait on the winner of the Melbourne/Footscray clash, but doubt remained over where the game would be held, with many Victorian based identities adamant that the MCG should host both preliminary finals to satisfy the AFL’s agreement with the MCC.

1994 Rewind: Eagles, Bulldogs Thrown Into Tribunal Chaos

September 4, 2019 ~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

West Coast claimed their second minor premiership with a 71 point thumping of Footscray in the final round, but the win was marred by a half-time brawl that ultimately dragged the club through a farcical AFL investigation.

The Bulldogs arrived in Perth in third position on the ladder on the back of six wins in seven games, but were no match for a West Coast side that had been given a boost by reigning premiers Essendon 24 hours earlier.

The Bombers had already been ruled out of finals action for 1994, but they doubled down on the misery of Carlton’s 1993 Grand Final defeat, with an upset 18 point win over the Blues that opened the door for West Coast to reclaim top spot.

The bye in round 23 had allowed several Eagles to recover from minor niggles but the break wasn’t enough for John Worsfold who missed with a groin strain. Craig Turley was also out, serving the first game of a two week suspension, allowing Chris Waterman to return after several weeks in the WAFL. Brett Spinks was the other inclusion when teams were first named.

Before the bounce, the Eagles made two further changes. Ashley McIntosh, Chris Mainwaring and Glen Jakovich had all been reported as struggling heading into the game, but it was Ryan Turnbull and Dean Kemp who were given an extra week of recovery. David Hynes and Tony Godden were brought in, with Hynes grasping the late opportunity with both hands.

Hynes put in a best on ground performance, controlling the ruck against Bulldogs counterparts Ilija Grgic and Barry Standfield. Hynes had 24 hit-outs (to the Bulldogs pair of 17), to go with 23 disposals and a goal. Don Pyke proved to be the greatest beneficiary from Hynes’ dominance, picking up 24 touches and capping off a fine game with three second half goals.

Pyke was too good for Simon Atkins early, gathering eight first quarter possessions, before Bulldogs coach Alan Joyce swung seven-gamer Brad Johnson onto the Eagle ruck rover. Chris Mainwaring and David Hart topped the ball-getters for West Coast with 25 each, while there was a strong spread of goal kickers with Pyke, Jason Ball and Chris Lewis leading the way with three each.

Lewis was magical across the half forward line having a hand in several goals from his 17 disposals and eight marks, while the Eagles defence again stood strong, conceding just six goals to the Bulldogs.

The Bulldogs had few winners on the day but Scott West and Tony Liberatore each finished with 18 touches through the middle, while Chris Grant had 11 disposals and seven marks roaming up the ground and also booted two goals.

West Coast jumped to a 20 point lead at quarter time, building their lead to 37 at the main break with only inaccurate kicking preventing the margin from being greater. The Eagles then booted four goals in each of the next two quarters, while the Bulldogs were held goalless in the last term. With the game in their keeping, West Coast turned their attention to the first final, resting a host of players in the final term, which saw them even finish with just 16 players on the ground.

The routine win was soon overshadowed when the focus turned onto the half-time brawl that involved most players on the ground.

The incident first began following a shirtfront on Brett Heady from Steve Wallis along the boundary line moments before the half time siren.

That caused remonstration between players, which quickly escalated as players rushed from all over the ground and even those that were on the bench.

With players tangled up, the brawl took a disturbing turn when Eagles spearhead Peter Sumich was taken into a headlock from rookie Bulldogs defender Danny Southern. Sumich blacked out on the ground and with the teams eventually dispersing and heading into the changerooms, the West Coast medical staff remained on the ground to tend to their full forward.

Eagles coach Mick Malthouse also remained on the field, opting to watch over Sumich until he was stretchered into the changerooms. Sumich would play no further part in the game, with the Eagles doctors eventually reviving the Eagles full-forward following several minutes on an oxygen tank.

Tensions remained high between the two sides through the second half, despite the one-sided scoreline. Southern – who had spent time with West Coast a couple of seasons earlier as he rehabilitated from a knee injury suffered while playing at Claremont – became the target of verbal abuse at the final siren from both Glen Jakovich and Jason Ball.

**Peter Sumich is attended too after being choked into unconsciousness by Danny Southern**

After the game, Malthouse described the brawl as a ‘blight’ on the game. “We come here to play football.”

“We can accept solid bumps and we can accept that footy is a physical game. But there were certain elements of today’s game that have surprised and disappointed us.”

No match-day reports were laid by umpires, with the clubs then the centre of an AFL investigation, led by Max Crawford. After Crawford spoke individually with both clubs, he found that no players should be charged, with AFL general manager Ian Collins supporting the findings and declaring both clubs would be fined $20,000.

However, Eagles officials were left stunned 24 hours later when the AFL overruled both Crawford and Collins to charge five West Coast players for their part in the melee. Glen Jakovich, Jason Ball, Tony Evans, Chris Lewis and Peter Sumich were all summoned to face the AFL judiciary five days after the game took place.

Jakovich copped two charges for striking Richard Osborne and Danny Southern, as did Ball who had two striking charges on Ilija Grgic and Chris Grant. Sumich was also charged for striking Grgic, while Chris Lewis and Tony Evans each received one charge for striking Doug Hawkins, who suffered a torn abdominal muscle during the fracas.

The Bulldogs weren’t spared with three players also called up to face the tribunal. Chris Grant was cited for striking Jakovich and Darcy MacPherson was cited for striking Lewis, while Danny Southern faced the more serious charge of conduct unbecoming for his headlock on Sumich.

West Coast general manager Brian Cook expressed the thoughts of both clubs, whose finals preparations were now under serious threat. “We are extremely disappointed and somewhat shocked. This has thrown our finals preparations into turmoil.”

The Bulldogs dropped to fifth at the completion of the home and away season, falling behind North Melbourne and Geelong who both recorded large wins in round 24. North Melbourne moved back to third when they comfortably accounted for the Magpies in the opening game of the round. The Kangaroos controlled the game from the outset, with eight goals to John Longmire delivering a 64 point win.

That left the Magpies nervously waiting on other results to stay in the finals hunt, but their place in the top eight was confirmed the following day when Richmond were trounced by Geelong. Despite being without Gary Ablett, the Cats were never troubled, running out 76 point winners as Bill Brownless replicated Longmire’s haul of eight goals.

Having suffered horrid defeats of 113 points to the Blues and 76 points to the Cats in the final two rounds of the season, it would be Richmond who were relegated to ninth position after Melbourne won a high scoring clash against the Swans to move back into the top eight.

The Tigers finished on 12 wins – the same as Melbourne and Collingwood – but had lost nearly 10 percentage points in the previous fortnight to finish well behind the Demons and Magpies. Geelong, on the other hand, found themselves inside the top four for the first time since Round 10 on the back of a late season revival after coach Malcolm Blight was at risk of losing his job midway through the year.

With Melbourne and West Coast recording wins on the Sunday, the first week finals schedule had been set. The Demons rose to seventh to book a first week final against Carlton, with North Melbourne to host Hawthorn and the Cats and the Dogs to square off.

That left eighth-placed Collingwood with the unenviable task of travelling to Perth to tackle the Eagles in a virtual elimination final, although who West Coast would have available for the game still remained up in the air.

With Footscray due to play their qualifying final on the Saturday night, the Bulldogs immediately sought an injunction with the Victorian Supreme Court to delay the tribunal hearings for Grant, MacPherson and Southern until the following Monday.

With the Bulldogs successful, West Coast considered a similar tack.

Ultimately, the Eagles decided to push ahead with the hearings with the five players to face the AFL tribunal less than 48 hours before they were due to play Collingwood.

Eagles Chairman Dwane Buckland denied that West Coast had missed the boat in joining the Bulldogs in submitting a joint injunction, as a war of words broke out between the two clubs.

The Bulldogs had responded in the wake of Malthouse’s post-match comments, calling their former coach’s words as ‘untrue, outrageous and defamatory’.

Footscray coach Alan Joyce was particularly pointed towards his counterpart. “I have been coaching in the AFL for several years now and I just wish other coaches, particularly Malthouse in Perth, would have the same degree of professionalism.”

General manager Dennis Galimberti went even further, defending the actions of Danny Southern and declaring it was the West Coast players who instigated the whole melee.

“The incident between Steve Wallis and Brett Heady was totally fair and within the rules of the game,” Galimberti said.

“As a result of the collision, several West Coast Eagles players ran a considerable distance to remonstrate with Wallis. That was the single thing that incited the events that followed.”

The Bulldogs were particularly critical of Malthouse speaking about the incident between Southern and Sumich, saying that it was inappropriate for comments to be made before the case was put to the tribunal.

Malthouse had stated that Sumich ‘was grabbed from behind by a bloke who came from their bench and was virtually strangled’

Malthouse retorted, saying he had never named Southern.

“You would have to be blind not to see the Channel 7 replay and determine the player responsible for Sumich’s condition,” Malthouse said. The Eagles coach also rejected suggestions he had confronted Southern at three quarter time. “I did not utter one word to Danny Southern. I can honestly say I did not utter one word to any Footscray player and I would never do that, never.”

Ultimately, West Coast decided to send their players to the tribunal, with the hearing taking place less than 48 hours before their finals match against Collingwood and the night after they had announced their squad for the game.

Buckland said that it was the view of the Board to have the matter dealt with before the clubs first final, to ensure that any potential penalties handed down could be served earlier in the finals campaign.

“If you are going to have a few players out, we’d prefer to have them out in a game we can afford to lose, rather than a game we can’t afford to lose.”

In the end, Buckland and the Eagles had nothing to worry about.

After a marathon four hour hearing, via video link up from Perth, all five West Coast players were cleared of any wrongdoing. The Eagles even called up Crawford as one of their own witnesses, to reiterate his view that no players should be charged over the melee.

**Eagles players leave the tribunal after having their charges thrown out.**

The Bulldogs would subsequently front the tribunal after the weekend with Grant and MacPherson equally cleared of any wrongdoing, while Southern was hit with a $10,000 fine.

After a week of disruption, West Coast were happy to move on from the whole situation and turn their attention into their match with Collingwood.

“Where it went off the rails I don’t know. And we are not going to pursue it,” a relieved Buckland declared.