Tag: mainwaring

1994 Rewind: Eagles, Bulldogs Thrown Into Tribunal Chaos

~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

West Coast claimed their second minor premiership with a 71 point thumping of Footscray in the final round, but the win was marred by a half-time brawl that ultimately dragged the club through a farcical AFL investigation.

The Bulldogs arrived in Perth in third position on the ladder on the back of six wins in seven games, but were no match for a West Coast side that had been given a boost by reigning premiers Essendon 24 hours earlier.

The Bombers had already been ruled out of finals action for 1994, but they doubled down on the misery of Carlton’s 1993 Grand Final defeat, with an upset 18 point win over the Blues that opened the door for West Coast to reclaim top spot.  

The bye in round 23 had allowed several Eagles to recover from minor niggles but the break wasn’t enough for John Worsfold who missed with a groin strain. Craig Turley was also out, serving the first game of a two week suspension, allowing Chris Waterman to return after several weeks in the WAFL. Brett Spinks was the other inclusion when teams were first named.

Before the bounce, the Eagles made two further changes. Ashley McIntosh, Chris Mainwaring and Glen Jakovich had all been reported as struggling heading into the game, but it was Ryan Turnbull and Dean Kemp who were given an extra week of recovery. David Hynes and Tony Godden were brought in, with Hynes grasping the late opportunity with both hands.

Hynes put in a best on ground performance, controlling the ruck against Bulldogs counterparts Ilija Grgic and Barry Standfield. Hynes had 24 hit-outs (to the Bulldogs pair of 17), to go with 23 disposals and a goal. Don Pyke proved to be the greatest beneficiary from Hynes’ dominance, picking up 24 touches and capping off a fine game with three second half goals.

Pyke was too good for Simon Atkins early, gathering eight first quarter possessions, before Bulldogs coach Alan Joyce swung seven-gamer Brad Johnson onto the Eagle ruck rover. Chris Mainwaring and David Hart topped the ball-getters for West Coast with 25 each, while there was a strong spread of goal kickers with Pyke, Jason Ball and Chris Lewis leading the way with three each.

Lewis was magical across the half forward line having a hand in several goals from his 17 disposals and eight marks, while the Eagles defence again stood strong, conceding just six goals to the Bulldogs.

The Bulldogs had few winners on the day but Scott West and Tony Liberatore each finished with 18 touches through the middle, while Chris Grant had 11 disposals and seven marks roaming up the ground and also booted two goals.

West Coast jumped to a 20 point lead at quarter time, building their lead to 37 at the main break with only inaccurate kicking preventing the margin from being greater. The Eagles then booted four goals in each of the next two quarters, while the Bulldogs were held goalless in the last term. With the game in their keeping, West Coast turned their attention to the first final, resting a host of players in the final term, which saw them even finish with just 16 players on the ground.

The routine win was soon overshadowed when the focus turned onto the half-time brawl that involved most players on the ground.

The incident first began following a shirtfront on Brett Heady from Steve Wallis along the boundary line moments before the half time siren.

That caused remonstration between players, which quickly escalated as players rushed from all over the ground and even those that were on the bench.

With players tangled up, the brawl took a disturbing turn when Eagles spearhead Peter Sumich was taken into a headlock from rookie Bulldogs defender Danny Southern. Sumich blacked out on the ground and with the teams eventually dispersing and heading into the changerooms, the West Coast medical staff remained on the ground to tend to their full forward.

Eagles coach Mick Malthouse also remained on the field, opting to watch over Sumich until he was stretchered into the changerooms. Sumich would play no further part in the game, with the Eagles doctors eventually reviving the Eagles full-forward following several minutes on an oxygen tank.

Tensions remained high between the two sides through the second half, despite the one-sided scoreline. Southern – who had spent time with West Coast a couple of seasons earlier as he rehabilitated from a knee injury suffered while playing at Claremont – became the target of verbal abuse at the final siren from both Glen Jakovich and Jason Ball.

Peter Sumich is attended too after being choked into unconsciousness by Danny Southern

After the game, Malthouse described the brawl as a ‘blight’ on the game. “We come here to play football.”

“We can accept solid bumps and we can accept that footy is a physical game. But there were certain elements of today’s game that have surprised and disappointed us.”

No match-day reports were laid by umpires, with the clubs then the centre of an AFL investigation, led by Max Crawford. After Crawford spoke individually with both clubs, he found that no players should be charged, with AFL general manager Ian Collins supporting the findings and declaring both clubs would be fined $20,000.

However, Eagles officials were left stunned 24 hours later when the AFL overruled both Crawford and Collins to charge five West Coast players for their part in the melee. Glen Jakovich, Jason Ball, Tony Evans, Chris Lewis and Peter Sumich were all summoned to face the AFL judiciary five days after the game took place.

Jakovich copped two charges for striking Richard Osborne and Danny Southern, as did Ball who had two striking charges on Ilija Grgic and Chris Grant. Sumich was also charged for striking Grgic, while Chris Lewis and Tony Evans each received one charge for striking Doug Hawkins, who suffered a torn abdominal muscle during the fracas.

The Bulldogs weren’t spared with three players also called up to face the tribunal. Chris Grant was cited for striking Jakovich and Darcy  MacPherson was cited for striking Lewis, while Danny Southern faced the more serious charge of conduct unbecoming for his headlock on Sumich.

West Coast general manager Brian Cook expressed the thoughts of both clubs, whose finals preparations were now under serious threat. “We are extremely disappointed and somewhat shocked. This has thrown our finals preparations into turmoil.”

The Bulldogs dropped to fifth at the completion of the home and away season, falling behind North Melbourne and Geelong who both recorded large wins in round 24. North Melbourne moved back to third when they comfortably accounted for the Magpies in the opening game of the round. The Kangaroos controlled the game from the outset, with eight goals to John Longmire delivering a 64 point win.

That left the Magpies nervously waiting on other results to stay in the finals hunt, but their place in the top eight was confirmed the following day when Richmond were trounced by Geelong. Despite being without Gary Ablett, the Cats were never troubled, running out 76 point winners as Bill Brownless replicated Longmire’s haul of eight goals.

Having suffered horrid defeats of 113 points to the Blues and 76 points to the Cats in the final two rounds of the season, it would be Richmond who were relegated to ninth position after Melbourne won a high scoring clash against the Swans to move back into the top eight.

The Tigers finished on 12 wins – the same as Melbourne and Collingwood – but had lost nearly 10 percentage points in the previous fortnight to finish well behind the Demons and Magpies. Geelong, on the other hand, found themselves inside the top four for the first time since Round 10 on the back of a late season revival after coach Malcolm Blight was at risk of losing his job midway through the year.

With Melbourne and West Coast recording wins on the Sunday, the first week finals schedule had been set. The Demons rose to seventh to book a first week final against Carlton, with North Melbourne to host Hawthorn and the Cats and the Dogs to square off.

That left eighth-placed Collingwood with the unenviable task of travelling to Perth to tackle the Eagles in a virtual elimination final, although who West Coast would have available for the game still remained up in the air.

With Footscray due to play their qualifying final on the Saturday night, the Bulldogs immediately sought an injunction with the Victorian Supreme Court to delay the tribunal hearings for Grant, MacPherson and Southern until the following Monday.

With the Bulldogs successful, West Coast considered a similar tack.

Ultimately, the Eagles decided to push ahead with the hearings with the five players to face the AFL tribunal less than 48 hours before they were due to play Collingwood.

Eagles Chairman Dwane Buckland denied that West Coast had missed the boat in joining the Bulldogs in submitting a joint injunction, as a war of words broke out between the two clubs.

The Bulldogs had responded in the wake of Malthouse’s post-match comments, calling their former coach’s words as ‘untrue, outrageous and defamatory’.

Footscray coach Alan Joyce was particularly pointed towards his counterpart. “I have been coaching in the AFL for several years now and I just wish other coaches, particularly Malthouse in Perth, would have the same degree of professionalism.”

General manager Dennis Galimberti went even further, defending the actions of Danny Southern  and declaring it was the West Coast players who instigated the whole melee.

“The incident between Steve Wallis and Brett Heady was totally fair and within the rules of the game,” Galimberti said.

“As a result of the collision, several West Coast Eagles players ran a considerable distance to remonstrate with Wallis. That was the single thing that incited the events that followed.”

The Bulldogs were particularly critical of Malthouse speaking about the incident between Southern and Sumich, saying that it was inappropriate for comments to be made before the case was put to the tribunal.

Malthouse had stated that Sumich ‘was grabbed from behind by a bloke who came from their bench and was virtually strangled’

Malthouse retorted, saying he had never named Southern.

“You would have to be blind not to see the Channel 7 replay and determine the player responsible for Sumich’s condition,” Malthouse said. The Eagles coach also rejected suggestions he had confronted Southern at three quarter time. “I did not utter one word to Danny Southern. I can honestly say I did not utter one word to any Footscray player and I would never do that, never.”

Ultimately, West Coast decided to send their players to the tribunal, with the hearing taking place less than 48 hours before their finals match against Collingwood and the night after they had announced their squad for the game.

Buckland said that it was the view of the Board to have the matter dealt with before the clubs first final, to ensure that any potential penalties handed down could be served earlier in the finals campaign.

“If you are going to have a few players out, we’d prefer to have them out in a game we can afford to lose, rather than a game we can’t afford to lose.”

In the end, Buckland and the Eagles had nothing to worry about.

After a marathon four hour hearing, via video link up from Perth, all five West Coast players were cleared of any wrongdoing. The Eagles even called up Crawford as one of their own witnesses, to reiterate his view that no players should be charged over the melee.

Eagles players leave the tribunal after having their charges thrown out.

The Bulldogs would subsequently front the tribunal after the weekend with Grant and MacPherson equally cleared of any wrongdoing, while Southern was hit with a $10,000 fine.

After a week of disruption, West Coast were happy to move on from the whole situation and turn their attention into their match with Collingwood.

“Where it went off the rails I don’t know. And we are not going to pursue it,” a relieved Buckland declared.

1994 Rewind: Eagles Secure Top Two

~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

West Coast ensured they would finish in the top two at the close of the home and away season when they held off a rampaging North Melbourne at the WACA, in the opening game of Round 21.

The Eagles put in one of their best defensive efforts of the year when they held the free-flowing Kangaroos to just three goals to three quarter time to lead by 40 points.

But the Kangaroos rallied, kicking the last five goals of the game to have the home side and the home fans nervous, with only some desperate defence in the final minutes putting a halt to a famous comeback.

The win meant that the Eagles sat four games clear of North Melbourne with three matches remaining to confirm a top two finish. However, West Coast were yet to receive confirmation from the AFL that a top two finish would equate to two home finals under the new top eight finals format.

Subiaco Oval was due to start comprehensive construction of the new Southern Stand immediately following the Eagles final round game against Footscray and the WACA had yet to be accepted as an alternative venue due to its smaller capacity.

The AFL were also locked into an agreement with the MCC that stipulated a final at the MCG every week, and while the remaining seven positions on the ladder were filled with Victorian sides, the AFL refused to confirm West Coast would receive a second home final beyond the opening week.

The situation mirrored the scenario that West Coast faced in 1991 when they were forced to travel for a semi-final against Melbourne and a preliminary final against Geelong, despite finishing top.

While that was still to play out between West Coast and the AFL, on the field two of the premiership fancies showed their best and their worst in front of an electric crowd of just under 32,000 people. 

Both teams named strong line-ups with the Eagles bringing back three premiership players in captain John Worsfold and half-forwards Tony Evans and Brett Heady. Guy McKenna was able to take his place despite still nursing a broken nose from a Darren Jarman hit the week before, as did Ryan Turnbull who was limited during the week at training with a left wrist complaint.

The Kangaroos made just the one change to the team that narrowly lost to Geelong the week before, with midfielder Alastair Clarkson making way for utility Peter Mann. North Melbourne coach Denis Pagan admitted that the selection of Mann was in response to the 37 point defeat to West Coast earlier in the season, when the Eagles exposed the Kangaroos for lack of height.

Another inclusion to the Kangaroos side from the one that lost in round 6 was Corey McKernan who had been a revelation in his first season. The rookie ruckman/forward had added another dimension to the Kangaroos in 1994 and lined up in the forward half along with Wayne Carey and John Longmire in a three-pronged attack.

Jason Ball was given the task in defence of minding McKernan, with Michael Brennan taking Longmire and Glen Jakovich matching up with Carey in the next instalment of their individual rivalry.

Jakovich would emerge the winner out of their battle with a best on ground display. The Eagles centre half back finished with 29 disposals and seven marks as he often stood in the way of many North Melbourne forward entries.

He was well supported by Guy McKenna (19 disposals) and John Worsfold (20 disposals) as North Melbourne allowed the Eagles half-back line to dictate play.

The Kangaroos used Alex Ishchenko as a spare man in defence, replicating a tactic that had worked successfully against Gary Ablett the week before. With Ishchenko heading into the back 50 after contesting the centre bounce, the Kangaroo half-forwards pushed up the ground to neutralise the Eagle midfield.

That meant McKenna and Worsfold were often allowed to set up without an opponent, feeding off the loose balls created from spilled balls in the North Melbourne forward 50.

The Eagles also had plenty of winners through the middle of the ground as Dean Kemp, Peter Matera and Chris Mainwaring dominated the North Melbourne centreline. Kemp dismissed the tagging effort of Anthony Stevens to pick up 12 first-half possessions and also booted the only two goals of the second quarter as West Coast worked their way to a 22 point half-time lead.

While Kemp was less influential after half-time, Mainwaring got the better of Wayne Schwass with 18 second-half disposals to finish with a match haul of 25 (along with eight marks). Peter Matera tallied 23 disposals on the other wing and Don Pyke was just as effective with 22 touches.

After controlling the first half, the Eagles were dominant in the third term, but it took until late in the quarter when consecutive goals to Craig Turley – who started the game on the bench – gave the Eagles what appeared to be an unassailable lead.

At three-quarter time, Pagan reverted back to a more typical structure holding his half-forwards deeper and the Kangaroos got the rewards on the scoreboard. They opened the scoring in the first minute before Peter Sumich responded shortly after with his second major of the evening to restore the Eagles’ 40 point lead.

That would be the last significant score for West Coast in the game as North Melbourne flew home in a rush. The Kangaroos kicked the final five goals of the game and had their chances in the dying minutes. With the margin just nine points and still three minutes remaining, the Kangaroos butchered several forward 50 entries.

Jakovich twice was able to intercept North Melbourne, including one John Blakey kick when he had Carey 15m free in space. Jakovich had 12 disposals and took four marks in the final term alone as the Eagles defence stood tall in the face of repeat Kangaroo entries.

After the match, the mood of the two coaches could not have been further apart.

Denis Pagan was seething of his side’s performance, with many of his prime movers leaving their imprint on the game until it was too late. Corey McKernan, Wayne Schwass and Darren Crocker all lifted in the final term as North Melbourne rallied, but it mattered little to Pagan.

“We were pretty disappointing for three quarters, and to come back hard in the last quarter proved that there is nothing conclusive about West Coast and North Melbourne.”

On the flipside, Mick Malthouse wasn’t bothered by his team’s last quarter, instead choosing to focus on the earlier effort that won the game.

“I thought the workload of the boys was outstanding for three quarters and there probably wasn’t any reward on the scoreboard.”

“North got their momentum up and they were very hard to stop… we got a couple of running injuries and that put a bit of pressure on us,” Malthouse explained. “We had to leave a couple of players out there when we wouldn’t have normally.”

In the post-script, both sides had setbacks to counter.

The Eagles finished the game without a fit player on the bench after John Worsfold and Tony Evans re-aggravated injuries in their first games back, while Chris Lewis had fresh worries over a thigh.

North Melbourne lost Anthony Rock during the game with a serious ankle injury, that was likely to see the midfielder miss the remainder of the regular season, but their concerns lay more critically with the tribunal.

The Kangaroos had three players reported on the night, with Brett Allison and Corey McKernan both reported for tripping Jason Ball on separate occasions, while Glenn Archer went into the book for disputing an umpires decision. Archer and Allison would escape suspension, but McKernan would not be so lucky, copping a one week ban. Cruelly, the guilty finding would leave McKernan ineligible for the Rising Star award, which he had been favourite to win.

If the nine-point win on a Friday night was a positive way to start the weekend, it only got better for the Eagles when Carlton – who were vying with West Coast for top spot – were humbled by last-placed Sydney at the SCG.

In a result that David Parkin declared would ‘have severe ramifications for the club’, the Swans recorded a famous eight-point win in a low-scoring clash, despite four goals to Carlton captain Stephen Kernahan. The Blues entered the game as $1.05 favourites, but the upset defeat left Carlton two games behind West Coast in second place ahead of their meeting the following week.

An inaccurate Richmond dropped their match against Hawthorn, while a goalless last quarter saw Melbourne fall to the Magpies. The losses to the Tigers and the Demons, on top of defeats to the Blues and Kangaroos meant that the teams placed second through to fifth coming into round 21 all lost, as the race for the top four got tighter.

The six teams behind West Coast and Carlton all had 11 wins for the season, with percentage determining the order.

North Melbourne remained third courtesy of their superior percentage with the Bulldogs moving into the top four after they easily accounted for St Kilda. The Saints got the early jump, but Footscray took control after quarter time, booting 15 goals to 6 on their way to a 45 point victory.

Geelong moved up to fifth when they got over the Lions, although it took until the last quarter to be completely assured of the win. Hawthorn, Collingwood and Richmond rounded out the eight, with the Magpies returning to the top eight after knocking on the door for several weeks.

Richmond suddenly looked vulnerable as they dropped from fourth to eighth, with their poor percentage threatening to undo their run to the finals. Melbourne made way for the Magpies dropping to ninth, as they sat one game behind the teams above them; the loss to Collingwood proving a real eight-point result.

1994 Rewind: Scarves & Swamps

~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

West Coast retained their premiership favouritism and Eagles fans got to exact their revenge but the biggest talking point after West Coast’s 36 point win over Essendon was the dilapidated surface of Subiaco Oval.

With Perth in the midst of an uncharacteristic wet spell, Subiaco Oval resembled more of a muddy swamp than its customary fast-track, drawing the ire of Eagles coach Mick Malthouse.

The Eagles coach seemed more interested in savaging the state of the surface than discussing his side’s committed win over the reigning premiers. With one side of the stadium torn down ahead of the building of the new southern stand, Malthouse was sceptical over whether there had been appropriate care towards maintenance of the playing arena, with drainage around the ground, virtually non-existent.

Malthouse extended his criticism towards the WAFC in the hope that improvements would be made before the end of the season.

And when the Eagles coach did talk about his side’s performance, he remained stoically understated.

The game appeared done at quarter time with the Eagles jumping the Bombers booting five goals to one. Any chance of Essendon staging a comeback was extinguished at the start of the second term when driving rain descended the game into a quagmire.

By three-quarter time, West Coast had extended their lead to 45 points, before the two teams combined for 1.9 in the last quarter, with the two teams out on their legs in the heavy conditions.

The win kept West Coast at the top of the ladder a game ahead of the Blues, with Malthouse acknowledging that a win over the 1993 premiers gave a good indication of where the Eagles sat. “I believed if you want to assess yourself you have to do it against the previous year’s premiership side. Last year everyone wanted to have a crack at us to see where they sat.”

“I think after the halfway mark if you are on top, you should really aspire to stay there. It is tough enough to get there and its going to be tough to stay there”, Malthouse said.

More pleasing for Malthouse was the successful return of Peter Sumich, who made it through four quarters, despite having little impact. Sumich was held scoreless from three kicks but there was relief after the game that the full-forward had managed to get through his first full game in over three months. “Peter did everything we wanted from him today,” Malthouse said.

Sumich was one of two inclusions, with Eagles captain John Worsfold finally making it to his 150th game after missing two of the previous three games. Sumich replaced David Hynes at full forward, while Shane Bond was the other exclusion through injury. Brett Spinks became the third out for the Eagles on game day, after being under an injury cloud all week, with Tony Godden coming in for his first game since Round 10.

The Bombers dropped Glenn Kilpatrick and Robert Stevenson, while their hero from the Round 1 win over West Coast, Che Cockatoo-Collins, couldn’t be considered after he dislocated a finger. Captain Mark Thompson was then a fourth change for the Bombers, when he was withdrawn on the morning of the game through illness.

David Grenvold replaced Thompson, with Anthony Daniher, Lachlan Ross and Russell Williams the other inclusions. The Bombers had been hopeful of bringing back a number of premiership stars for the trip West, but the likes of Mark Mercuri (groin), Dean Wallis (achilles), Rick Olarenshaw (back) and David Flood (hamstring) remained sidelined.

Dustin Fletcher, Michael Long and Mark Harvey were three more premiership players missing from the Essendon line-up, a fact that Malthouse was willing to present. “Essendon had three or four key players out of the side so we don’t want to get carried away with the victory.”

The make-up of the Bombers side would not have mattered to Eagles fans, who got their right of reply to Kevin Sheedy’s antics 12 months earlier. In the corresponding game of 1993, Sheedy emerged from the coaches box waving his jacket above his head after Paul Salmon had snatched a two point win over the Eagles in the final minute of the game.

The Eagles had lost the two meetings since that game – the semi final of 1993 and then the opening round of 1994, both of which had been played in Melbourne – but as Kevin Sheedy walked the muddy boundary line towards the Bombers race, he was met with the mass celebration of scarves and jackets twirling above the heads of the jubliant Eagles crowd. The Essendon coach could do no more, than acknowledge the gesture with a wry smile and a nod of the head.

The Essendon coach is met with flying scarves after the Eagles 36 point win

If Sumich lasting 100 minutes was one feel good factor from the day, the other pleasing performance for the Eagles match committee would have been that of Craig Turley. After returning to the club following his retirement during the 1993 season, Turley’s form had been rather indifferent as he struggled to recapture the form that made him one of the premier midfielders of the preceding two seasons.

But against the Bombers, Turley bobbed up with three crucial goals from 12 disposals across half-forward as he appeared to revel in the tough, slippery conditions. Turley was also handed the task of stopping Essendon playmaker Gary O’Donnell, with the stand-in captain restricted to just 11 possessions, and a couple of stints on the bench.

The Eagles wingmen were again the standouts, with Chris Mainwaring leading the way with 27 disposals, while Peter Matera finished with 24 touches and five shots on goal, booting 2.3. Mainwaring benefitted from being matched against Darren Bewick, who had been moved to a wing to avoid the tag of David Hart. Bewick had enough of the ball (finishing with 18 possessions) but was nowhere near as damaging as the blonde Eagle, who continually linked the ball from defence to the forward line.

Glen Jakovich was again the rock in defence, picking up 22 disposals in his absorbing battles with James Hird. Hird often drifted up to the wing, but Jakovich remained in the Eagles defensive 50, often setting up as the Eagles seventh defender. Steven Alessio was sent to centre half forward to create a match-up with Jakovich, but Jason Ball was sent to defence, allowing Jakovich to pick off Essendon’s forward entries, many off Hird himself.

Ryan Turnbull also enjoyed plenty of freedom around the ground and had an important influence on the contest, particularly early in the game. With Paul Salmon often dropping a kick a behind the play after contesting the ruck, Turnbull positioned himself through the middle of the ground, drifting forward twice in the opening term to boot goals.

Peter Wilson picked up 22 disposals around the ground and Dean Kemp had 20 through the centre, although he lowered his colours slightly to Joe Misiti who finished with 25 disposals.

James Hird was the next best for Essendon, after Misiti, with 24 disposals and seven marks, while Sean Denham had 21. Gavin Wanganeed was switched forward after half-time and gathered 19 disposals, but the Bombers lacked few options forward of centre. Third-gamer Scott Cummings was the only winner in the Essendon forward line, booting three of the Bombers’ five goals for the game.

Sheedy was left to lament a poor attitude from his side in the opening quarter, which ultimately decided the game. “We were very undisciplined in the first quarter. It cost us dearly.”

One such incident involved Gary O’Donnell choosing to wrestle with Eagles captain John Worsfold, rather than contest a loose ball, which allowed Turley to stroll in and boot one of his three goals.  

While declaring that ‘the Eagles were looking pretty good’, Sheedy admitted that his side would have a battle to make finals, after they dropped to seventh on the ladder, amongst a strong group of teams vying for the lower spots in the top eight.

Richmond climbed to sixth on the ladder when they recorded a narrow three point win over Footscray, in what was a virtual eight-point clash. The Bulldogs dropped out of the top eight as a result, replaced by Geelong who, off the back of 10 goals from Gary Ablett, defeated Melbourne by 30 points.

At the pointy end of the table, Carlton and Hawthorn both recorded ten goal wins over Adelaide and St Kilda, respectively, to maintain their chase of West Coast. Collingwood moved into the top four after they beat Fitzroy by 49 points at the Western Oval, moving past North Melbourne who had the bye.

1994 Rewind: Wall of Jakovich Halts Cats

~ wcehistory ~ Leave a comment

It was a case of the Eagles taking their chances and the Cats ruing theirs when West Coast bounced back from their loss to Collingwood with an 18 point win over Geelong at Kardinia Park.

Glen Jakovich was arguably the difference between the two sides, with the hulking centre half back picking up 28 disposals and 10 marks in a best on ground display. Jakovich had the better of first Barry Stoneham and then Leigh Colbert with Geelong coach Malcolm Blight unable to diffuse the Eagle’s output.

“The biggest problem we had all day was Jakovich. Forget the rest,” an exasperated Blight remarked after the game.

Jakovich had spent much of the week in doubt with a shoulder injury, but he proved to be an integral part in the Eagles win. Jakovich combined well with Guy McKenna who rebounded strongly off the half-back flank, while Tony Evans produced his best performance of an injury-interrupted season with four goals up forward.

Evans was considered lucky to have held his spot after managing just five disposals the week before, but several others weren’t so fortunate as West Coast made a raft of changes. Karl Langdon, Paul Harding and Matt Clape were all dropped, while Brett Spinks was ruled out with concussion.

Coming into the Eagles line-up were Jason Ball, David Hynes, captain John Worsfold and debutant Paul Symmons. Symmons’ inclusion capped a whirlwind week for the skinny redhead, after he was named best afield for Western Australia in their state league match against South Australia the previous week.

The inclusion of Hynes and Ball was with the intention of giving the Eagles forward line greater presence after Mick Malthouse thought too much reliance had been placed on mid-sized forwards Chris Lewis and Brett Heady the week before.

Peter Sumich remained sidelined as the Eagles opted for caution on their full forward. Sumich, along with Worsfold and Shane Bond, had undergone a fitness test before the squad departed for Geelong, but only Worsfold was declared fit.

The Cats were missing their own spearhead in Bill Brownless, who had not made an appearance since being dropped after the round 10 defeat to Essendon. Geelong, though, still brought back three important players in Leigh Colbert, Leigh Tudor and Peter Riccardi, who was set to resume his battle on the wing with Peter Matera. Sean Simpson was then the Cats’ fourth inclusion when he replaced Leigh Pickering ahead of the bounce.

But while there was no consternation when the team was announced, there were plenty of raised eyebrows when the teams lined up at the opening bounce.

Blight – not immune to thinking outside the box – abandoned his traditional attacking nature by starting many of his playmakers in unorthodox positions in a bid to match the Eagles defensive style. Garry Hocking lined up at half-forward, Robert Scott was sent to a back pocket on Evans, while Paul Couch – who had shown form in the previous month that was reminiscent of his 1989 Brownlow win – started on the bench.

Steven Hocking and Sean Simpson were both moved into the middle in tagging roles on Dean Kemp and Don Pyke, while Grant Tanner was given a similar task on the wing opposed to Chris Mainwaring. Ken Hinkley went to half-forward matching up against McKenna, with Andrew Wills sent to defence on Chris Lewis.

The moves worked for the first 30 seconds when Mark Bairstow was able to win the opening clearance and find Gary Ablett, who snapped the opening goal. But that was about as effective as Blight’s changes got.

Dean Kemp had nine first-quarter possessions – trailing only Jakovich on the ground who had 11 – and Tony Evans was proving too elusive for Robert Scott in the forward line. Chris Lewis was proving equally as difficult for Wills and the Cats were lacking drive with Hocking and Couch not involved in the game.

Two late goals put the Eagles in front at quarter time and they continued to dictate play in the second term. The Cats stuck to the task for the majority of the term, but again West Coast were able to nab a pair of goals late in the quarter to head into half-time with a 17 point advantage.

Kemp had tallied 17 disposals in the first half as he shook off the tagging effort of Steven Hocking, as did Jakovich who had restricted Stoneham to just seven disposals and no marks. Mainwaring picked up seven kicks and three handpasses in the second term to take him to 14 for the half, with Matera also recording 14 disposals in the first half on the other wing.

With the Eagles midfield controlling the game, Blight was forced to do away with his defensive tactics and resort back to Plan A, bringing Couch off the bench and putting he and Garry Hocking in the middle. West Coast booted the first two goals after the main break to stretch their lead to a game high 29 points, but Hocking soon dragged the Cats back into the contest.

The Cats midfielder went head to head with Kemp and had the better of the Eagle as Geelong got more ball in their forward half. However, for all their ball, they were continually met with the imposing presence of Jakovich.

Stoneham was moved to centre half back at the start of the third term, switching positions with Leigh Colbert who had struggled to contain Ashley McIntosh. Colbert moved to centre half forward and tried to drag Jakovich out of the play, but it was to no avail.

The Cats though still managed to kick the final two goals of the third term and Mark Bairstow could have made it three in a row after the siren, only to see his set shot hit slam into the post. Trailing by 22 points at the final change, the Cats continued to push, closing within eight points.

But they failed to capitalise on their chances with Gary Ablett and Tim McGrath, in particular both missing gettable shots. West Coast finished with the final two goals of the game to seal the four points in Chris Mainwaring’s 150th game, but Geelong’s 2.6 in the last term blew any chance they had of stealing the win at the death.

“It was a game of chances, I thought. When we had control of the game in the last quarter we didn’t take ours,” Blight said. The Geelong coach refused to accept that his positional changes at the start of the game had played into the Eagles hands, instead saying they were in the game but couldn’t make their shots on goal count.

Garry Hocking ended with 33 possessions, 21 of which came in the second half, while Paul Couch collected 19, despite spending the best part of half the game on the bench. Gary Ablett finished with four goals, but was well held by Michael Brennan and John Barnes had 18 disposals to go with 25 hit-outs through the middle.

Jakovich’s 28 disposals was the second-best effort in his career and he was the leading ball winner for the Eagles, ahead of Kemp who had 27. Guy McKenna had 25 and Mainwaring finished with 22 touches in his milestone game.

Remarkably, the win was the Eagles’ fourth in a row against Geelong at Kardinia Park, stretching back to 1989. In that time, they had also won twice against the Cats at Waverley Park and twice at the MCG, making it eight consecutive wins over Geelong in Victoria. On the flipside, they had lost twice at home in that same period.

Mick Malthouse was confident that his side would bounce back from their disappointing showing against Collingwood. “We have very rarely lost two in a row. The players responded to direct criticism during the week,” Malthouse proclaimed.

“If that’s the character they showed, then Geelong showed it too. It was a tough game from go to whoa. It was only in the last minute that I put my headphones down.”

When asked about Jakovich’s performance, Malthouse was naturally understated. “Good young player.”

The win maintained the Eagles position at the top of the ladder, one game ahead of Carlton who had defeated North Melbourne by 18 points in their Friday night blockbuster. The Blues leapfrogged the Kangaroos into second spot, with North Melbourne dropping to third. The Hawks held onto fourth position despite having the bye.

Footscray were the big winners of the round, rocketing from ninth to fifth when they thrashed Fitzroy by 104 points. The Bombers defeated Sydney by 34 points but fell behind the Bulldogs on percentage, while the Magpies were the latest team to fall victim at the GABBA, losing to the Bears by 44 points.

Richmond’s narrow win over Melbourne had them knocking on the top eight, while Adelaide missed a golden chance to jump back into the finals spots when they were held to a draw by lowly St Kilda. The Cats remained in eighth spot on percentage, with Malcolm Blight under increasing pressure to hold his position as senior coach.

A fortnight earlier, Blight had been booed by his own fans at three-quarter time when Geelong trailed the Saints by 26 points at home, only to have his blushes saved when the Cats stormed home to win by three points. With a 6-6 record after 12 games, Geelong were well short of expectations and reports of tension between players and the coach were surfacing.

However, Geelong president Greg Durham allayed any suggestions that Blight’s position was under threat, confirming the experienced coach wasn’t going anywhere.